Best All the Feels Hallmark Fancast Podcasts (2025)

1
Ep 121: A Grand Ole Opry Christmas vs Christmas at the Catnip Cafe 47:09

Play Pause

1d ago47:09

47:09

Will "Christmas at the Catnip Cafe" claw its way into this week's winner circle or can "A Grand Ole Opry Christmas" boot-scoot into the top spot? We also detour into childhood snow-day memories and share our thoughts on this year's Macy's Thanksgiving parade!By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 120: Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story vs Melt My Heart This Christmas 41:51

10d ago41:51

41:51

Mel, Dory, and Erika gather to discuss the season’s fourth bracket matchup: Holiday Touchdown: A Bills Love Story vs Melt My Heart This Christmas. Did either movie give the ladies all the feels? Plus, they chat about their epic trip to Dollywood and the Finding Mr. Christmas elimination they’ve been waiting for since week 1.…

1
Ep 119: Three Wisest Men vs Tidings for the Season 39:48

17d ago39:48

39:48

The star power of Hallmark's three coolest weirdos goes up against B.J. Britt's thousand-watt smile in our Three Wisest Men vs. Tidings for the Season match up. Plus, the unexpected downside of a 12-foot Christmas tree, an unintentional prison love story, and a Christmas mystery that baffles the ladies of All The Feels. It feels important to mentio…

1
Ep 118: Christmas Above the Clouds vs A Keller Christmas Vacation 37:13

25d ago37:13

37:13

What do holiday baking shows, family cruise vacations, and men in turtlenecks have in common? Absolutely nothing—but we discuss all of them as we attempt to stay on topic while reviewing Christmas Above the Clouds vs A Keller Christmas Vacation.By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 117: Christmas on Duty vs A Newport Christmas 56:00

1M ago56:00

56:00

It’s our first matchup of the season! Christmas on Duty vs. A Newport Christmas. In this episode, Mel, Dory, and Erika discuss identity theft, the “science” of time travel, Finding Mr. Christmas, holiday doormats, and, of course, which movie won the weekend.By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 116: 2025 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket 1:05:08

1M ago1:05:08

1:05:08

A Hard Candy Countdown to Christmas season has arrived, as it appears the recession has hit our beloved Hallmark. With almost half the amount of holiday movie premieres this season, it is a slimmed-down episode with far less debating as Dory, Mel, and Erika sift through the contenders to fill in the 2025 All The Feels Countdown to Christmas movie b…

1
Ep 115: Hanukkah on the Rocks vs The Santa Class 1:06:15

12M ago1:06:15

1:06:15

Ugh, it's the moment we dread every year - the end of the bracket! In our final bracket match up, Double Dare nostalgia goes up against a charming amnesia Santa - and then, an overall winner of the season is crowned! Which Hallmark Countdown to Christmas movie will be declared our #1 pick? Other pressing questions - Are we in a Hallmark Renaissance…

1
EP 114: Private Princess Christmas vs Leah's Perfect Gift 1:12:19

12M ago1:12:19

1:12:19

It's the penultimate match-up of the season and we're not ready to let go! This week pits Private Princess Christmas against Leah's Perfect Gift...and, well, it's basically a TKO from the jump (I think I understand sports?) Then the ladies go deep on the highs and lows of Hallmark+, and how their love affair of the season ultimately broke their hea…

1
Ep 113: Deck The Walls vs Holiday Touchdown 1:02:26

1y ago1:02:26

1:02:26

Thanks to Hallmark's much anticipated Thanksgiving premiere week, we've got ourselves an epic showdown happening! It's Deck The Walls up against Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story. These movies gave us a whole lot - a roller skating party, team spirit, housewives references, and even a cat dressed as a quarterback. Tune in to see which movie ta…

1
Ep 112: Christmas on Call vs Three Wiser Men and a Boy 39:26

1y ago39:26

39:26

Before life gets chaotic with all things Thanksgiving, join us as we match up Christmas on Call versus Three Wiser Men and a Boy. Can a sequel take the win or will romance in the city of Brotherly Love prevail? And of course, we'll share our thoughts on Finding Mr. Christmas (let's face it - this lil' reality show has become a weekly talking point)…

1
Ep 111: Hot Frosty vs Jingle Bell Run 1:05:20

1y ago1:05:20

1:05:20

Dory, Mel, and Erika might have found their first frontrunner of the season! Will it be Hot Frosty or Jingle Bell Run? Also, the ladies place their bets on who they think will win Finding Mr. Christmas.By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 110: Trivia at St. Nick's vs Santa Tell Me 51:31

1y ago51:31

51:31

Trivia at St. Nick's and Santa Tell Me are the Hallmark offerings going head to head in our third bracket match up - one is greeted with mixed reviews and one with a resounding HELL YES MORE PLEASE. Which Nick would Dory, Mel, and Erika pick? The answer may (not) surprise you! Also, the ladies just can't help but sink a snowboot further into the cr…

1
Ep 108: The Christmas Charade vs The Five Year Christmas Party 43:22

1y ago43:22

43:22

It's the beginning of the 2024 Hallmark Holiday Movie bracket and we're kicking things off with The Christmas Charade vs A Five Year Christmas Party. Not only do we discuss these two movies filled with FBI hijinks and theatre dreams, we also gab about ageism, punk trick-or-treaters, and Beyonce because why not?! Note: After recording this episode, …

1
Ep 109: A Carol for Two vs Holiday Mismatch 50:45

1y ago50:45

50:45

Week two is in the books, and the whole gang is back together. In this episode, Dory, Mel, and Erika talk about singing servers, meddling mothers, and Hallmark hunks. Will the Cyrano-style setup of A Carol for Two beat out Holiday Mismatch, aka a Sabrina the Teenage Witch reunion? Listen to find out!…

1
Ep 107: 2024 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket 2:00:51

1y ago2:00:51

2:00:51

We're back and ready for another round of Hallmark Christmas crazy! In this extra-extra-long episode (blame it on Hallmark's bloated movie summaries) Erika, Dory, and Mel debate this season's Countdown to Christmas offerings, narrowing the field to the lucky hopefuls that will compete in the 2024 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket. We've got Kelce…

1
Ep 106: Magic In Mistletoe vs Christmas On Cherry Lane 1:17:43

2y ago1:17:43

1:17:43

It’s hard to believe, but we’ve come to the end of the road (cue the Boyz II Men). In our last episode of the season, Dory, Mel and Erika gather one more time to discuss our final movie matchup, Magic in Mistletoe vs. Christmas on Cherry Lane, and to crown a bracket champion. We had some strong contenders this year. Listen to find out who took the …

1
Ep 105: My Norwegian Holiday vs A Not So Royal Christmas 56:18

2y ago56:18

56:18

This week's Hallmark Bracket movies bring us quaint European towns awash with trolls, woolen stockings, long-lost-family, long-lost-Counts, and LIES! My Norwegian Holiday goes up against A Not So Royal Christmas in this season's second to last match-up - and the ladies of All The Feels are once again divided. Also included are deep thoughts on fate…

1
Ep104: Holiday Road vs Haul Out The Holly: Lit Up 52:05

2y ago52:05

52:05

Ooooohhh, talk about a match-up! We've got Holiday Road vs Haul Out the Holly: Lit Up. With tons of characters between these two movies, did we love them all or was it overwhelming? Plus, you know what they say about sequels - was Lacey's second installment on Evergreen Lane a hit or a miss? We also reminisce about slumber parties and share a sligh…

1
Ep103: A Merry Scottish Christmas vs Catch Me If You Claus 40:33

2y ago40:33

40:33

Match-up number five puts A Merry Scottish Christmas up against Catch Me If You Claus. There's a lot of love for the beauty of Scotland, but the ladies ain't mad at a steamy make-out session either! Plus, we talk turkey, thanksgiving favorite foods, and get a second appearance from Mel's Dad!By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 102: Mystery on Mistletoe Lane vs Christmas Island 42:48

2y ago42:48

42:48

It’s hard to believe, but we’re already halfway through this year’s bracket! Mystery on Mistletoe Lane and Christmas Island compete in our fourth matchup of the year, and it’s safe to say that Andrew Walker had us all swooning. But was his charisma enough to help Christmas Island win the weekend? As usual, this episode has lots of movie talk and lo…

1
Ep 101: Never Been Chris'd vs The Santa Summit 1:01:24

2y ago1:01:24

1:01:24

The third bracket match up brings us two movies about friendship, and causes a heated debate for the ages between the ladies of All The Feels. Never Been Chris'd goes up against The Santa Summit - in one we stand united, in the other - divided. Where will you stand when the Christmas dust settles?By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 100: Mystic Christmas vs Joyeux Noel 1:04:58

2y ago1:04:58

1:04:58

It’s our 100th episode! In true All the Feels fashion, we didn’t realize this momentous occasion was upon us, so we had to commemorate it on the fly. Then, Hallmark takes us from an aquarium in Connecticut to a Christmas market in France as Mystic Christmas takes on Joyeux Noel in our second matchup of the season. Thank you for sticking with us for…

1
Ep 99: Where Are You, Christmas? vs Under The Christmas Sky 39:18

2y ago39:18

39:18

The 2023 Hallmark Holiday Movie bracket kicks off with a black & white Christmas-less universe vs. a lot of angst and party planning involving the actual universe. Where Are You, Christmas? goes up against Under the Christmas Sky in a not-so-heated premiere weekend match up - plus, Cher has a new Christmas album! And it's not even Halloween yet! En…

1
Ep 98: 2023 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket 1:14:30

2y ago1:14:30

1:14:30

It's Christmas-time in Hallmark Land which means bring on the bracket! Erika, Dory, and Mel reconvene to examine (scrutinize) this season's crop of Countdown to Christmas offerings, carefully selecting the contenders that will face off in the 2023 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket. We've got astronauts and fish friends and trolls and royals and s…

1
Ep 97: A Royal Christmas Crush vs. Take Me Back for Christmas 1:14:18

2y ago1:14:18

1:14:18

The All The Feels 2023 Holiday Bracket is coming soon! Until then, please enjoy this Christmas in July episode, where Dory, Mel, and Erika chat about A Royal Christmas Crush and Take Me Back for Christmas. This eclectic episode also includes discussions about high school reunions, Barbie, the Hallmark cruise, Taylor Swift, and our favorite comfort …

1
Ep 96: Summer Catch Up & Vanderpump Rules! 1:16:24

2+ y ago1:16:24

1:16:24

It's a special Summertime Session of All The Feels where Erika, Dory, and Mel gather to touch on their off-season Hallmark viewing, (mainly Mahogany and Mysteries) and how the writer's strike may affect our beloved holiday hallmark season. They also discuss what else they've been enjoying - including a long and passionate deliberation on their late…

1
Ep 95: Holiday Heritage vs Hanukkah on Rye 1:35:34

3y ago1:35:34

1:35:34

Erika is back just in time for the final match-up of the season - and is teeming with stories of mishaps and maladies from her very special Disney Family Vacation. Then, after a whirlwind of Kwanzaa and latkas and Lisa Loeb, a 2022 Hallmark bracket winner is crowned! In a holiday season full of big swings and surprisingly great movies - the elimina…

1
Ep 94: The Most Colorful Time of the Year vs The Holiday Sitter 1:25:59

3y ago1:25:59

1:25:59

Dory and Mel are joined by their friend Lisa to chat about The Most Colorful Time of the Year and The Holiday Sitter, our second to last matchup of the season. Topics discussed in this eclectic episode include Twitter drama, color blindness, chimney mishaps, Jonathan Bennett’s mustache, diversity and inclusion on Hallmark, online dating profiles, B…

1
Ep 93: A Big Fat Family Christmas vs Undercover Holiday 46:38

3y ago46:38

46:38

Week 6 is in the books! This episode’s matchup is A Big Fat Family Christmas vs. Undercover Holiday, and Dory and Mel hold down the fort while Erika is away on her own Big Fat Family Christmas vacation. We also discuss the hair bows in A Fabled Holiday, Reese Witherspoon’s 2014 movie The Good Lie, Harry & Meghan’s Netflix docuseries, and more.…

1
Ep 92: A Royal Corgi Christmas vs. A Holiday Spectacular 59:46

3y ago59:46

59:46

Erika is back and ready to take on our fifth Hallmark movie bracket match-up, A Royal Corgi Christmas versus A Holiday Spectacular! We've got stubby corgi legs going up against Rockette high kicks, family drama, deli dreamboats and the most evil dog handler in all the land. Sit back and join the ladies as they spiral over 1950s historical inaccurac…

1
Ep 91: Inventing the Christmas Prince vs. Three Wise Men and a Baby 57:00

3y ago57:00

57:00

While Erika is off celebrating an Ohio Thanksgiving, fellow Hallmark-enthusiast Lisa from the Y'all, This Book podcast joins Dory and Mel to break down the MOST! DIFFICULT! MATCH-UP! OF THE SEASON! (So far). Inventing the Christmas Prince takes on Three Wise Men & a Baby, pitting Tamera Mowry-Housley and a horse-drawn carriage against a trifecta of…

1
Ep 90: Falling for Christmas vs Christmas at the Golden Dragon 45:25

3y ago45:25

45:25

It’s official—Lindsay Lohan is back, baby! In this episode, Dory, Mel, and Erika discuss Lindsay’s new holiday movie, Falling for Christmas, our first-ever bracket entry from Netflix! But can LL’s star power help Falling for Christmas knock off Hallmark’s Christmas at the Golden Dragon? The answer might surprise you.…

1
Ep 89: Lights, Camera, Christmas! vs All Saints Christmas 38:45

3y ago38:45

38:45

Battling in week two on the holiday movie bracket is Lights, Camera, Christmas! and All Saints Christmas. While getting into the holiday spirit, the ladies talk New Orleans vibes, Hollywood movie star winks and butt deodorant?! Whaaa?! Plus, a glowing recommendation on a non bracket flick will have you running to your TV to tune in.…

1
Ep 88: A Cozy Christmas Inn vs. Jolly Good Christmas 58:21

3y ago58:21

58:21

The first bracket match-up of the season is here, where an unexpected Full House alum goes head to head with an American (??) Will Kemp and the magic of London at Christmas. Join us as we discuss the pros and cons (and cons and cons) of a sequel without the Original Recipe romance, and the glory that is Reshma Shetty's green jumpsuit. Plus a short …

1
Ep 87: 2022 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket 1:20:52

3y ago1:20:52

1:20:52

We’re back, baby! In this episode, Dory, Mel, and Erika unveil the 2022 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket. Which Hallmark movies will be competing for the top spot? Will Lifetime be back on the bracket after a disappointing showing last year? Is a new network coming for Hallmark’s crown? We have so much to discuss, so pour yourself a cup of hot c…

1
Ep 86: A Dickens of a Holiday! vs Sister Swap: Christmas in the City 1:24:17

4y ago1:24:17

1:24:17

The final bracket match-up of the season is here and a true Hallmark expert is in the house! Joining the ladies is Bubbly Sesh host Shawl and we have a Dickens! of a time choosing between the sizzling Polaha-D'Orsay chemistry in "A Dickens of a Holiday!" and the charismatic party planning/Queen of Dory's heart Ashley Williams in "Sister Swap: Chris…

1
Ep 85: Our Christmas Journey vs Sister Swap: A Hometown Holiday 1:03:21

4y ago1:03:21

1:03:21

After swapping out Lifetime movies for Hallmark in the last two bracket battles, Dory, Mel and Erika match up Our Christmas Journey vs Sister Swap: A Hometown Holiday. Come for the reviews and stay for a hodgepodge of other topics including indoor Christmas tree lots, tap dancing, expired vision boards and a mispronunciation that brings the ladies …

1
Ep 84: Merry Liddle Christmas Baby Vs. Miracle In Motor City 1:16:51

4y ago1:16:51

1:16:51

Dory, Mel and Erika assemble once again to discuss their week six bracket matchup, featuring Merry Liddle Christmas Baby vs. Miracle in Motor City. Expect lots of rants and lots of laughs as the ladies are joined by their friend Ryan, who shares his experience as a contestant on Wheel of Fortune and his hopes for one day competing on Survivor.…

1
Ep 83: Dancing Through the Snow vs Baking Spirits Bright 46:50

4y ago46:50

46:50

The first Lifetime match-up of the bracket brings the ladies a ballet dancing widow, fruitcake rebranding woes, and tons of befuddlement, annoyance, and concern about the many Lifetime movies that lay before them. Dancing Through the Snow takes on Baking Spirits Bright, one barely eking out a win to the next round of the All The Feels Christmas Mov…

1
Ep 82: One December Night vs A Holiday in Harlem 53:49

4y ago53:49

53:49

The ladies welcome back friend of the pod, Kevin and together, they battle One December Night vs. A Holiday in Harlem in this week's bracket. Plus there's talks of a cross-country RV trip, applauding representation and an epic Christmas fashion show!By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 81: Next Stop, Christmas vs A Christmas Treasure 49:20

4y ago49:20

49:20

This week’s matchup is Next Stop, Christmas vs. A Christmas Treasure, which both aired on the Hallmark Channel. In this episode, Mel gives us a rant for the ages while Dory and Erika fight about time travel. This is one you don’t want to miss!By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 80: Christmas in Harmony vs Christmas Sail 39:34

4y ago39:34

39:34

It's Round 2 of the All the Feels Holiday movie bracket match up, where Hallmark's Christmas in Harmony and Christmas Sail battle to win our hearts. In a Halloween weekend full of gospel choirs, magical boat parades, lovers to enemies, friends to lovers, Terry O'Quinn, buckets of grief, and 1/3rd of Destiny's Child...the choice proves to be a diffi…

1
Ep79 - Boyfriends of Christmas Past vs The Santa Stakeout 47:59

4y ago47:59

47:59

We're skipping right past the witches, skeletons, jack o'lanterns and breaking out the reindeer, snowmen and Santas because it's week one of the All The Feels Holiday bracket! We got ex-boyfriends in the form of ghosts battling undercover detectives but only one movie will move ahead. Aaaaaaand, thanks to changing air dates, we already have some re…

1
Ep 78: 2021 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket 54:39

4y ago54:39

54:39

It’s the most wonderful time of the year! In this episode, Dory, Mel and Erika reunite to hash out their 2021 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket. Will a Hallmark or Lifetime movie will come out on top? Watch along with us to find out!By All the Feels Hallmark Fancast

1
Ep 77: All The Drama 59:23

4y ago59:23

59:23

Something wicked this way comes as the ladies gather pre-Halloween and pre-Christmas kick-off to address all of the drama swirling through the Hallmark-verse. Topics include the Curious Case of the Good Witch finale, the Christmas TV Movie Wars, cheerful anti-vaxxers, and which Hallmark pups are most favored by Dory's dog, Zero. Warning: Two F-bomb…

1
Ep 76: The Vows We Keep 1:18:35

4y ago1:18:35

1:18:35

Our friend Antonio Cayonne is back! In this episode, he joins Dory and Mel to discuss his new movie for Hallmark Movies and Mysteries, The Vows We Keep. The ladies also talk to Antonio about his experience on The Mighty Ducks: Game Changers, diversity and inclusion efforts in the entertainment industry, his growing restaurant businesses, and of cou…

1
Ep 75: March Check In 2021 1:12:01

4+ y ago1:12:01

1:12:01

Spring is springing ahead, hope is (hopefully) blooming, and it's the perfect time to return for a warm-weather check in! In this episode, Erika, Dory, and Mel set Hallmark aside to discuss two recent cultural milestones: Oprah's interview with Meghan & Harry, and the Hulu documentary "Framing Britney Spears". Family drama, spirals, and sadness abo…

1
Ep 74: 2020 Bracket Winner! 55:15

5y ago55:15

55:15

It's Christmas, (Eve) and the final match-up is here! After Hallmark's Love, Lights, Hanukkah! competes against Lifetime's A Christmas Exchange, a 2020 Holiday Movie Bracket winner is crowned! And man, what a hard, hard choice it is to make in such a truly standout year. Dory, Erika and Mel also discuss highs and lows of the season, Hallmark movies…

1
Ep 73: The Christmas Setup vs. A Sugar & Spice Holiday 55:40

5y ago55:40

55:40

Our 2020 All The Feels Holiday Movie Bracket Challenge is almost over, and Lifetime gave us two strong contenders this week: The Christmas Setup vs. A Sugar & Spice Holiday. Both movies were groundbreaking in their own ways and both gave us all the feels, but only one could come out on top. Listen now to find out which movie won the weekend in our …

1
Ep 72: Christmas In Evergreen 4 vs Christmas Ever After 1:15:16

5y ago1:15:16

1:15:16

It's Hallmark vs Lifetime in the 6th match-up of the season as Christmas in Evergreen 4 battles Christmas Ever After. On one side, we got our favorite new Hallmark couple in our #1 Christmas town with its (perhaps) magical red truck. And on the other, we have a romance novelist who heads to her favorite Christmas lodge only to see the leading man f…

All The Feels Hallmark Fancast Podcasts