Best Crit Fails Podcasts (2026)

1
Full Show - 2026 Outlook For Jets, Giants, Plus, Cody Bellinger Watch, Steve Gelbs & Chris Broussard 2:48:24

Play Pause

23h ago2:48:24

2:48:24

Jerry and Willie Colon put a cap on 2025 with a packed New Year’s Eve show.. From Willie’s "trial by fire" debut with Mike Francesa and the "kumbaya" culture of modern athletes to the fallout of Pete Alonso’s Mets exit and the Yankees’ pursuit of Cody Bellinger. The guys navigate everything from Trevon Diggs' release and "out of control" college at…

1
Hour 1 - Athlete Media Lessons, Giants Hard Knocks Star, Cowboys Cut Diggs 46:48

23h ago46:48

46:48

Jerry and Willie Colon end 2025 with a New Year’s Eve mix of locker room lessons and office chaos. From Willie’s legendary first encounter with Mike Francesa and his "kumbaya" critique of modern athletes to the mystery of finding expired 2014 Mountain Dew in the studio. The guys dive deep into the Jets' effort issues, the Trevon Diggs fallout, and …

1
Hour 2 - Look Ahead To '26 & The Jets Outlook, Plus, Best QB Gifts & Top Moments Of 2025 43:45

23h ago43:45

43:45

Jerry and Willie Colon look ahead to 2026 as they debate the future of the New York Jets and why firing Aaron Glenn would be a historic shocker. Willie reveals the best (and worst) gifts he ever received from his QBs—including a legendary gesture from Ryan Fitzpatrick—before Jerry wraps up the year with the top 5 "Moments of the Day" from 2025.…

1
Hour 3 - Steve Gelbs On Jets, Mets, More Debut Tapes, Willies' Vision Boards 40:11

23h ago40:11

40:11

SNY’s Steve Gelbs joins the show to break down the fallout of the Mets letting Pete Alonso walk and what it’s actually like surviving this Jets season behind the scenes with Willie. CLo unearths classic WFAN "debut" tapes of Jacob Wilkins with Mike Francesa, before diving into Joe Burrow’s special breakfast habits. Willie shares his family’s New Ye…

1
Hour 4 - Cody Bellinger, CFP Starts, Chris Broussard On NFL & Knicks 37:38

24h ago37:38

37:38

Jerry and Willie dive into the Yankees’ pursuit of Cody Bellinger and why the "perfect fit" for the Bronx is still waiting on a deal. The guys talk college sports—featuring unfiltered takes from John Calipari and Rick Pitino—before FS1’s Chris Broussard joins to talk NFL, Lamar Jackson’s health and the Knicks' championship ceiling.…

1
FS1's Chris Broussard Checks In 13:56

24h ago13:56

13:56

FS1’s Chris Broussard joins the show to discuss NFL playoff scenarios, Lamar Jackson’s return to practice and the Knicks’ chances of winning it all.

1
Waiting For Cody 7:14

24h ago7:14

7:14

Both the Mets and Yankees are waiting for Cody Bellinger to make a decision...any decision.

1
The Tradition Of Vision Boards 6:40

1d ago6:40

6:40

Willie explains his family tradition of making vision boards on New Year’s Eve. It’s a way to go into the new year with some positive energy and trying to hold yourself accountable to achieving goals.

1
Steve Gelbs Joins Us To Talk Jets, Mets & Alonso 19:16

1d ago19:16

19:16

Steve breaks down what it’s really like sharing the desk with Willie Colon during a chaotic Jets season and gives his take on the Mets’ offseason—including the move to let Pete Alonso walk in free agency.

1
Top 5 "Moments Of The Day" 11:25

1d ago11:25

11:25

Jerry presents his pick for the best of best of moments that make you laugh or cringe or both.

1
Looking Ahead To 2026 Sports 13:19

1d ago13:19

13:19

Willie and Jerry are looking ahead to the 2026 NY sports landscape. The Jets finished 2025 in the cellar, but Willie explains why Aaron Glenn’s job is safer than the fans might think.

1
Giants Kicker Ben Sauls: Hard Knocks Star, Plus, Cowboys Cut Trevon Diggs. 6:24

1d ago6:24

6:24

The Cowboys move on from Trevon Diggs, Hard Knocks finds a new star, and a mixed bag for NY hockey.

1
Learning What Not To Do In The Media 11:17

1d ago11:17

11:17

Willie Colon share a story about his first time on the air with Mike Francesa. Willie breaks down the jarring reality of moving from the locker room to the media room and reveals a specific lesson learned from a teammate's blunder. We wrap things up with a dive into Caleb Williams’ growth and whether he’s finally living up to the Chicago hype.…

1
WFAN Changes and Spending Too Much on Food | 'Al & Jerry's Postgame Podcast' 29:01

1d ago29:01

29:01

From 'Al & Jerry's Postgame Podcast' (subscribe here): Jerry and Rami Lavi: WFAN Changes and Spending Too Much on Food To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices…

1
Full Show - Glenn Backtracks On Crit, Iffy Ref Calls, Great Knicks & A Lot More 2:57:13

2d ago2:57:13

2:57:13

From ref fatigue on Monday Night Football to the baffling 180-degree turn from Aaron Glenn, we are breaking down a wild Tuesday in sports. Jerry and Willie Colon tackle the fallout of the Falcons' win over the Rams, questioning if the officiating crew has officially "checked out". Then a Jets roster that seems to have given up on the season. We’re …

1
Hour 1 - Controversial Ref Calls, Jets Backtracked Comments 45:28

2d ago45:28

45:28

Jerry and Willie kick things off with the Falcons’ wild MNF win over the Rams. Between a missed PI and a "catch" that wasn't, the refs are under fire—Willie thinks they’re fatigued and he wants real repercussions. Plus, Aaron Glenn is trying to put the toothpaste back in the tube after backtracking on his "lack of effort" comments. Jerry isn't buyi…

1
Hour 2 - Are The Knicks The Best? Plus, Jax Silences Critics 47:01

2d ago47:01

47:01

We kick off the hour with the Knicks rolling in New Orleans and the Jalen Brunson era hitting a new gear. Jerry is convinced they can take the East—but Willie is ready to take it a step further. Plus, the wind is howling in NY, leading to a "helpful" debate: Willie saw someone struggling in the gust yesterday and kept on walking... and Jerry and CL…

1
Hour 3 - Weird Trads To Mystery Meats & Even A Joe B Jets Rant 40:05

2d ago40:05

40:05

We’re diving into odd traditions - from the "First-Foot" ritual to Jerry finally learning what a "glizzy" is. Between debating if you’d skip being a Best Man for a Jets AFC Championship game and listening to Joe Benigno transition from Woody Johnson-induced rage into a Manscaped ad.. We wrap things up with a deep dive into "mystery meats" and the d…

1
Hour 4 - Coaches On The Hot Seat, Ravens-Steelers, Niners Path To The SB 44:37

2d ago44:37

44:37

Is Mike Tomlin a lock for Pittsburgh, and could John Harbaugh really be on the move? Willie explains why Tomlin is staying put but drops a bombshell on the Ravens’ QB situation, arguing he’d start Tyler Huntley over a banged-up Lamar Jackson this Sunday. Plus, we’re breaking down the 49ers' path to a home-turf Super Bowl and why Jerry is telling Ji…

1
What Can The NFL Do About Tanking? 8:57

2d ago8:57

8:57

Teams tank for a higher draft pick and it ends up being lousy football. Jerry has a solution.

1
Tomlin Ain't Goin' Nowhere 8:01

2d ago8:01

8:01

Are Mike Tomlin and John Harbaugh locks to return next season? Willie breaks down why Tomlin isn't going anywhere. He reveals his strategy for the Ravens—explaining why he’d roll with Tyler Huntley over a banged-up Lamar Jackson this Sunday.

1
Joe B Goes Jetsoid! 4:09

2d ago4:09

4:09

CLo delivers some audio of Joe Benigno. To nobody’s surprise he is not happy about the Jets. Joe had words for Woody Johnson on his podcast.

1
First Foot & Other Rituals 16:12

2d ago16:12

16:12

We begin the hour learning about the “First-Foot” tradition from callers. Willie feels vindicated and teaches us more stuff.

1
Jax Answers Critics While Aaron Glenn Causes Head Scratches 11:25

2d ago11:25

11:25

While Jaxson Dart is busy adjusting his game to silence the critics, Aaron Glenn is leaving everyone's heads spinning with his latest defense of the Jets. Jerry admits most coaches deserve time, but poses the big question: Has Glenn done anything well in year one? Plus, we’re breaking down Bijan’s 93-yard TD and why Willie thinks the Rams are exact…

1
Knicks Own The East, But What About The West 9:37

2d ago9:37

9:37

Jalen Brunson put on a masterclass in New Orleans, proving once again why he’s the engine that makes this team go. Jerry is sold on them dominating the East—but can they actually hang with the West’s best when the lights are brightest?

Crit Fails Podcasts

1
Crit Fail Club

Crit Fail Club

1
Crit Fails Inc

Crit Fails Inc.

1
Don't Crit Fail: A Juggalo Adventure

Robert Tidwell

1
Halfwits & Failed Crits

Halfwit Podcasts

1
Boomer & Gio

Audacy

1
Full Show - 2026 Outlook For Jets, Giants, Plus, Cody Bellinger Watch, Steve Gelbs & Chris Broussard 2:48:24

1
Hour 1 - Athlete Media Lessons, Giants Hard Knocks Star, Cowboys Cut Diggs 46:48

1
Hour 2 - Look Ahead To '26 & The Jets Outlook, Plus, Best QB Gifts & Top Moments Of 2025 43:45

1
Hour 3 - Steve Gelbs On Jets, Mets, More Debut Tapes, Willies' Vision Boards 40:11

1
Hour 4 - Cody Bellinger, CFP Starts, Chris Broussard On NFL & Knicks 37:38

1
FS1's Chris Broussard Checks In 13:56

1
Waiting For Cody 7:14

1
The Tradition Of Vision Boards 6:40

1
Steve Gelbs Joins Us To Talk Jets, Mets & Alonso 19:16

1
Top 5 "Moments Of The Day" 11:25

1
Looking Ahead To 2026 Sports 13:19

1
Giants Kicker Ben Sauls: Hard Knocks Star, Plus, Cowboys Cut Trevon Diggs. 6:24

1
Learning What Not To Do In The Media 11:17

1
WFAN Changes and Spending Too Much on Food | 'Al & Jerry's Postgame Podcast' 29:01

1
Full Show - Glenn Backtracks On Crit, Iffy Ref Calls, Great Knicks & A Lot More 2:57:13

1
Hour 1 - Controversial Ref Calls, Jets Backtracked Comments 45:28

1
Hour 2 - Are The Knicks The Best? Plus, Jax Silences Critics 47:01

1
Hour 3 - Weird Trads To Mystery Meats & Even A Joe B Jets Rant 40:05

1
Hour 4 - Coaches On The Hot Seat, Ravens-Steelers, Niners Path To The SB 44:37

1
What Can The NFL Do About Tanking? 8:57

1
Tomlin Ain't Goin' Nowhere 8:01

1
Joe B Goes Jetsoid! 4:09

1
First Foot & Other Rituals 16:12

1
Jax Answers Critics While Aaron Glenn Causes Head Scratches 11:25

1
Knicks Own The East, But What About The West 9:37