Best Indianapolis Colts Centrals Podcasts (2025)

1
Panic time for Colts after loss to Texans, a bold IU football prediction from Jake! | Episode 264 - 12.2.25 1:05:07

Play Pause

8h ago1:05:07

1:05:07

The guys talk about the Colts continuing their slide after a tough home loss to Houston and signing a new kicker after some issues at that spot. Also, a bold IU football prediction from Jake and Greg Rakestraw fills in for a vacationing Schultz! Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Sweet Chili Queso Coney Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Sa…

1
Colts collapse in K.C., AFC South up for grabs, ranked Purdue and IU! | Episode 263 - 11.25.25 1:04:05

13d ago1:04:05

1:04:05

The guys talk about the Colts blowing a late lead at Arrowhead and why it could spell doom in the suddenly tight AFC South divisional race. Plus, Boilers and Hoosiers ranked in hoops, Daniel Jones questions, and Jake's cultural learnings from spending a week in Austria. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Always Sunny Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew o…

1
Colts' brutal homestretch, NFL MVP open for Taylor? Kaufman-Renn appreciation! | Episode 262 - 11.18.25 59:48

20d ago59:48

59:48

The Athletic's Zak Keefer fills in for Jake Query as the guys discuss the post-bye gauntlet awaiting the Colts, starting with Patrick Mahomes and the desperate Chiefs. They also get into Jonathan Taylor's better than expected circumstances to force his way into true MVP contention, appreciate Purdue star Trey Kaufman-Renn, and talk Indiana's chance…

1
Jonathan Taylor does it again, Daniel Jones concerns and Omar Cooper saves the day! | Episode 261 - 11.11.25 1:05:10

27d ago1:05:10

1:05:10

In a chilly edition of the show from Chilly Water Brewing Co. tap room, the guys discuss the Colts' latest win and how it means good things for a team that is rounding into a supposed contender. Also, concerns with Daniel Jones, Omar Cooper's incredible catch in State College, and Schultz's propensity to withdraw from college courses. Hoagies & Hop…

1
Myles Turner gets booed in return, Colts sloppiness dooms them versus Steelers! | Episode 260 - 11.4.25 1:04:25

1M ago1:04:25

1:04:25

The guys discuss Myles Turner's return, his reception, and react to what he had to say postgame. Also, a discussion over whether baseball is having a moment again and why the Colts' loss in Pittsburgh may have just been a bad afternoon at the office. (*recorded a few hours before the Sauce Gardner trade, unfortunately) Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the …

1
Jonathan Taylor for MVP, Colts schedule gets tough, Pacers early injury woes! | Episode 259 - 10.28.25 1:10:25

1M ago1:10:25

1:10:25

Greg Rakestraw fills in for a traveling Schultz as the guys talk about Jonathan Taylor forcing his way into the MVP conversation, the early Pacers' start and more! Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Chili Cheese Coney Dogs Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Dr. Feel GoodBy Query & Schultz

1
Colts are NFL's best, Aaron Nesmith extension, World Series set! | Episode 258 - 10.21.25 1:08:43

2M ago1:08:43

1:08:43

The guys discuss the Colts' historic offensive performance through seven games as they sit atop the NFL standings at 6-1, get into the Aaron Nesmith extension with the Pacers, talk a little college football, and Jake pretends like he's always been a huge Toronto Blue Jays fan. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Zaire cheesesteak Chilly Water Brewin…

1
Colts MVP: Jones or JT? Why Cignetti might not leave IU! | Episode 257 - 10.14.25 1:09:29

2M ago1:09:29

1:09:29

On this week's episode, the guys jump into Indiana's program statement win in Eugene and some of the reasons why Curt Cignetti would stay and buck conventional wisdom when it comes to moving to a "better" program. Also, the guys give their picks for Colts MVP to this point and discuss why they feel like this is the year to strike in the AFC. Hoagie…

1
Colts rout Raiders, bad Mark Sanchez Situation takes, and Ashton Dulin appreciation! | Episode 256 - 10.7.25 1:09:19

2M ago1:09:19

1:09:19

By Query & Schultz

1
Colts blow chance in L.A., IU survives at Iowa, Jake's car troubles! | Episode 255 - 9.30.25 55:47

2M ago55:47

55:47

In the latest edition of Q & S, we're talking about the Colts' blown opportunity in L.A. but why we're still optimistic with their season outlook. Also, IU takes another step forward with a big road win, Andrew Nembhard takes over at PG1, and Jake's car troubles' saga continues. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Market Street Chilly Water Brewing …

1
Colts stay perfect, IU football no fluke, and Fever keep good vibes going! | Episode 254 - 9.23.25 1:09:02

3M ago1:09:02

1:09:02

The guys continue to sing the praises of Daniel Jones after another solid start and discuss whether Shane Steichen could have possibly seen this coming. Also, Indiana football continues to prove last season was no fluke, the Indiana Fever show they're not going down without a fight, and Jake reveals the naming games he plays while dealing with inso…

1
Colts stun Broncos, the good & bad of Shane Steichen, worried about ND? | Episode 253 - 9.16.25 1:12:55

3M ago1:12:55

1:12:55

The guys bask in the glow of the Colts' 2-0 start after a thrilling win over the Broncos, discussing the magnitude of the offensive performance against Denver's D and some of the good and bad we saw from Shane Steichen last Sunday. Also, a recap of the 10th anniversary Hoagies & Hops Hoagie Eating Contest and famous sports figures with the first na…

1
Colts clobber Dolphins in impressive opener and Daniel Jones rewards confidence | Episode 252 - 9.9.25 1:03:35

3M ago1:03:35

1:03:35

The guys recap an incredibly encouraging season-opening performance for the Colts and discuss what it may mean going forward, not only for the team but for Daniel Jones, too. Also, Week 2 college football wrap and a discussion on how famous people get in touch with other famous people. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Zern's Chilly Water Brewing …

1
Colts with a big opener against the Dolphins, Indiana and Purdue win, IndyCar news! | Episode 251 - 9.2.25 1:13:25

3M ago1:13:25

1:13:25

It's finally Colts' game week and the guys give their thoughts on a critical opener against fellow middle-dweller Miami and their season predictions for Indianapolis. Also, Purdue and IU secure Week 1 victories, Jake has an update on IndyCar silly season, and we spend some time with Kristina from Hoagies & Hops inside the restaurant! Hoagies & Hops…

1
Colts expectations, Richardson's future, IU's football encore! | Episode 250 - 8.26.25 1:05:04

3M ago1:05:04

1:05:04

The guys discuss their Colts' expectations in the wake of last week's QB1 decision, the possibility of an Anthony Richardson trade, why they're both semi-bullish on Indiana's chances to prove 2024 wasn't a fluke, and Jake's latest physical ailment. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Pitt Twist Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Santeria…

1
Debating Daniel Jones and Anthony Richardson at QB1 and assessing Colts' injuries! | Episode 249 - 8.19.25 1:08:31

4M ago1:08:31

1:08:31

(taped before Daniel Jones was officially named the starter, because OF COURSE) A final debate between Daniel Jones and Anthony Richardson for the Colts' starting quarterback spot and why Jake thinks it'll be Jones instead of AR. Plus, how the Colts injuries impact their early season start and a question of whether to retrieve lost items from a por…

1
Anthony Richardson or Daniel Jones, Colts' CB injuries, and SausageFest plugs! | Episode 248 - 8.12.25 1:06:47

4M ago1:06:47

1:06:47

The guys air some frustrations over no separation in the Colts' quarterback battle, discuss the myriad of injuries at a key position, argue over a disputed Top Indiana Sports Moment (according to ESPN), and Schultz gets his SausageFest plugs in. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Hog Island Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Loose Juicy…

1
Colts gear up for preseason test against Ravens and red-hot Indiana Fever! | Episode 247 - 8.5.25 59:56

4M ago59:56

59:56

The guys talk about the Colts' first game (kind of!) of the 2025 season and how AD Mitchell and Laitu Latu are starting to really come on in camp. Also, what the Fever's surge means for Caitlin Clark's timeline, appreciating Kyle Schwarber's insane run, and summer "floaters" in the pool. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Dutch Country Chilly Water…

1
Anthony Richardson is good starting position and remembering the icon Ryne Sandberg! | Episode 246 - 7.29.25 1:05:15

4M ago1:05:15

1:05:15

The guys jump into whether Anthony Richardson is leading the quarterback battle and what the Bernhard Raimann's contract extension means moving forward. Also, paying tribute to Ryne Sandberg, recapping Brickyard 400 weekend, and TMI about Schultz's grooming habits. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Market Street Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of th…

1
Colts biggest questions in Camp, WNBA All-Star Weekend recap, Coldplay re-enactment! | Episode 245 - 7.22.25 1:10:33

5M ago1:10:33

1:10:33

With training camp set to begin in Westfield, the guys talk about the biggest questions facing the Colts and try to look at a glass half-full approach. Also, a WNBA All-Star Weekend recap, remembering Bob Hammel, and a re-enactment of the Coldplay concert controversy between two best friends! Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Keystone Chilly Water…

1
A "gap year" for Pacers and the least anticipated Colts season ever? | Episode 244 - 7.8.25 1:05:04

5M ago1:05:04

1:05:04

The guys talk "gap year" for the Pacers with Tyrese Hailburton on the shelf and Myles Turner out the door to Milwaukee, while also reacting to Kevin Pritchard's postseason availability comments. Also, apathetic expectations for the 2025 Colts, remembering Don Hein and Dick Mittman, and Jake asks if The Sopranos is worth a watch. Hoagies & Hops Hoag…

1
Pacers draft & free agency questions and want an NHL or MLS team for Indy? | Episode 243 - 7.1.25 56:57

5M ago56:57

56:57

*taped hours before the Myles Turner news The guys discuss the two newest Pacers draft picks and where they might be going as far is free agency is concerned. Plus, a debate over whether Indy would better support an NHL or MLS team, remembering Dave Parker, and Derek discusses his summer pits (gross).…

1
Remembering the 2025 Pacers, Haliburton's injury, and where Indiana goes from here | Episode 242 - 6.24.25 1:05:06

6M ago1:05:06

1:05:06

The guys spend a majority of the show taking a look back at the 2025 Pacers, a special season that fell just short of a breakthrough championship. Also, in the wake of Tyrese Haliburton's devastating injury, where to the Pacers go from here? The guys discuss that and Query's weird list of favorite road trip games.…

1
Episode 241 - 6.17.25: Pacers on brink in NBA Finals, Haliburton's health, and great one at Gateway! 1:05:01

6M ago1:05:01

1:05:01

Jake and Rake (filling in for a vacationing Schultz) talk about the Pacers' first back to back losses in three months and if they can throw one last punch against the Thunder. Also, a look at Tyrese Haliburton's health entering a do-or-die Game 6 and Query's feelings on a terrific IndyCar show in St. Louis.…

1
Episode 240 - 6.10.25: Pacers return home even with Thunder, House settlement done, new Colts' ownership! 1:04:19

6M ago1:04:19

1:04:19

Can the Pacers take back control of the NBA Finals? The guys are hesitant to say so, even with Indiana returning home after getting a split. They talk about what it will take to get the best of the Thunder in what has become a best-of-five series, plus the House settlement, Colts' new ownership structure, and Schultz has a cough (again).…

1
Episode 239 - 6.3.25: Pacers march on to NBA Finals, early Indiana vs. OKC look, and more! 1:06:06

6M ago1:06:06

1:06:06

The guys discuss the Pacers' first trip to the NBA Finals in a quarter-century, what to expect from the Thunder, and who all deserves credit for this notable accomplishment (spoiler: just about everyone). Also, Derek has a weird gripe about state listings with cities and Jake breaks out an excellent piece of Indy-related NBA Finals trivia.…

1
Episode 238 - Can Pacers take back control, Palou's Indy breakthrough, remembering Irsay! 1:05:36

7M ago1:05:36

1:05:36

The guys get into the latest on the Pacers as they head into a critical Game 4 with New York after blowing a big opportunity. Plus, thoughts on Alex Palou's breakthrough, a "meh" 109th running of the Indianapolis 500, and the sad passing of the iconic Jim Irsay.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 237 - 5.19.25: Racers & Pacers: a huge Indy 500 pole upset, Pacers-Knicks first look! 1:00:45

7M ago1:00:45

1:00:45

The guys jump into the best sports week of the year in Indianapolis by talking about Robert Shwartzman's epic Pole Day upset, more Team Penske violations, and what to expect from the 9th (!) edition of the heated Pacers-Knicks rivalry.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 236 - 5.12.25: Pacers crush Cavs to move one win from East Finals and can anyone catch Alex Palou? 1:08:13

7M ago1:08:13

1:08:13

The guys finally avoid a Pacers' playoff night conflict to recap Indiana's Game 4 blowout win and what it means for the rest of the series. Plus, can anyone catch Alex Palou on the oval later this month and a random discussion of North Dakota's best all-time athletes (don't ask).By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 235 - 5.6.25: Pacers get the jump on Cleveland, Month of May begins, Mike Woodson coaching return? 59:48

7M ago59:48

59:48

The guys get into the Pacers' impressive opening game shooting performance in Cleveland and whether they can keep things rolling throughout the series. Plus, has IndyCar been boring heading into the Month of May, a potential Mike Woodson coaching return, and Jake gets hyper-focused on the greatest love stories ever told.…

1
Episode 234 - 4.29.25: Colts' unfilled needs after NFL Draft, Pacers put Bucks on brink, Jake's trademark! 1:04:44

7M ago1:04:44

1:04:44

The guys tie a bow on the Colts' 2025 NFL Draft class by taking a last look at Tyler Warren and discussing the needs that are still out there for the team. Plus, Jake and Derek disagree on if Pacers-Bucks is *over* over and Jake is attempting to capitalize on his own catchphrase.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 233 - 4.22.25: Colts' Draft week, can Pacers stay in control of Bucks, transfer portal craziness! 1:08:52

8M ago1:08:52

1:08:52

The guys take a look at how the Pacers can maintain the upper hand against the Bucks in their first round series, appreciate Andrew Nembhard, discuss the potential the Colts *don't* take Tyler Warren or a tight end at No. 14, and Jake looks back at forgotten superstars from past generations.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 232 - 4.15.25: Pacers get to 50 wins - Bucks next, Rory redemption, Braden Smith returns to Purdue! 1:12:05

8M ago1:12:05

1:12:05

The guys discuss the Pacers wrapping up a 50-season season and getting a rematch with a familiar foe in Round 1, touch on Rory's redemption in Augusta, Braden Smith's return, and Jake reveals a disturbing truth about his dental healthBy Query & Schultz

1
Episode 231 - 4.8.25: Florida topples Houston, Kelvin Sampson revisionist history, Tush Push yay or nay? 1:20:01

8M ago1:20:01

1:20:01

The guys recap a slugfest national title game between Florida and Houston and argue the Gators' place among the elite programs. Plus, defending Indiana in the Kelvin Sampson ouster in 2008, discussing the possible Tush Push ban, and debating Dwight Howard's Hall of Fame candidacy.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 230 - 4.1.25: Pacers in prime position, all-chalk Final Four, IU & Purdue in the portal! 1:13:16

8M ago1:13:16

1:13:16

The guys lead with the Pacers' strong March putting them in a great spot for the postseason, jump into a loaded Final Four and Kelvin Sampson's latest triumph, plus portal season for IU and Purdue and Derek offers Jake some eyebrow grooming advice.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 229 - 3.25.25: Purdue marches on to Sweet 16, Pacers in prime playoff position, boring Tournament? 1:05:01

9M ago1:05:01

1:05:01

The guys dive into college hoops - Purdue marching on to another Sweet 16, IU's portal situation, and the lack of Cinderellas in this year's dance. Plus, the Pacers are putting themselves in a great spot for postseason standing and Jake remains enamored with Arkansas.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 228 - 3.18.25: Did IU get snubbed, Purdue's chances, and a wild Pacers win in Minnesota! 1:09:01

9M ago1:09:01

1:09:01

The guys discuss whether or not Indiana was snubbed and North Carolina AD Bubba Cunningham chairing the selection committee. Also, Purdue's chances to avoid a trendy upset pick, a short-handed Pacers' overtime win in Minneapolis, and Jake's weird infatuation with Rick Barnes. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Zern's Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew o…

1
Episode 227 LIVE at Horizon Tournament - 3.10.25: Colts' free agency and plenty of hoops! 2:01:44

9M ago2:01:44

2:01:44

The guys are LIVE from the 2025 Barbasol Horizon League Championships at Corteva Coliseum! They talk the latest on Colts' free agency, IU and Purdue's status entering the Big Ten Tournament, and the beginning of The Madness! Plus, a conversation with Horizon League commissioner Julie Roe Lach.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 226 - 3.4.25: QB options for Colts, NFL Combine wrap, is IU off the bubble? 1:00:01

9M ago1:00:01

1:00:01

The guys discuss the potential QB options to "push" Anthony Richardson in this offseason's "open competition. Plus, a Combine wrap and what the Colts may do at No. 14, Indiana off the bubble, Purdue off the schneid, and Schultz's graphic look back at the day the sports world stopped in 2020.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 225 - 2.25.25: IU surges past slumping Purdue, NFL Combine begins, latest on Pacers! 1:03:01

10M ago1:03:01

1:03:01

The guys jump into Indiana and Purdue splitting their season series and what it means for both teams as the calendar soon turns to March. Also, a look at Jake's least-favorite sporting event of the year (the NFL Combine) and whether the Colts are dead set on a tight end at No. 14 and the guys compare hand sizes.…

1
Episode 224 - 2.18.25: NBA's All-Star problem, all-time SNL member, our IU coaching lists! 1:05:01

10M ago1:05:01

1:05:01

Derek returns from Arizona as the guys discuss fixing the NBA All-Star Weekend problem, their all-time Saturday Night Live cast member picks, go over their IU coaching candidate lists, and discuss Purdue's rough week in the Big Ten title race. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Pitt Twist Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: ARC…

1
Episode 223 - 2.11.25: Coaching search for Indiana, Super Bowl LIX reax, latest on Pacers! 1:09:02

10M ago1:09:02

1:09:02

The guys talk about another head coaching search in the works for the Hoosiers, react to a disappointing Super Bowl blowout, and discuss the latest involving the Pacers coming off their Western trip split. Greg Rakestraw fills in for a vacationing Schultz!By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 222 - 2.4.25: Why Myles Turner won't be traded, Fever going for it, Super Bowl LIX picks! 58:55

10M ago58:55

58:55

The guys discuss their apprehension with the Myles Turner trade rumors, get into the Fever going all in on a championship run, and give their brief thoughts on a uninspiring Super Bowl LIX matchup.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 221 - 1.28.25: End for Woodson (?), Chiefs' conspiracy theories, Drake Triumph returns! 1:07:07

10M ago1:07:07

1:07:07

The guys get into the latest hellish week for IU basketball and if we've reached the point of no return on the Mike Woodson era, plus responding to pro-Chiefs referee conspiracies, appreciating Saquon Barkley, and Drake Triumph returns in time for the Royal Rumble in Indy!By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 220 - 1.21.25: Ohio State new kings, Colts nab a DC, surging Purdue/surviving IU! 1:10:01

11M ago1:10:01

1:10:01

We recap last night's College Football Playoff title game and what the result means for Ohio State, Notre Dame, and the Big Ten. Plus, what to expect from Lou Anarumo's defense in Indy, Purdue hitting its stride and IU staying alive, and Schultz's weird audiobook preferences.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 219 - 1.14.25: Reacting to what Chris Ballard said, Mike Woodson's blowout problem, red-hot Pacers! 1:10:05

11M ago1:10:05

1:10:05

The guys react to Chris Ballard's press conference comments and play keep/walk/who cares with the impending Colts' free agents. Also, Mike Woodson's continuing blow out problem at IU, don't let those Pacers get hot, and what is the proper context for the word "girth"?By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 218 - 1.7.25: Colts keeping Ballard and Steichen after disappointing year and post-holiday hoops! 1:05:04

11M ago1:05:04

1:05:04

The guys react to Jim Irsay's decision to keep his braintrust intact for next season and how Colts' fans should take the news. Also, the Pacers climb over .500, some optimism about IU hoops, and the appropriate way to refer to using a snowblower.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 217 - 12.31.24: Colts embarrassed by awful Giants, decision(s) time for Jim Irsay, Pacers' latest! 1:09:40

11M ago1:09:40

1:09:40

In the final show of 2024, the guys recap Sunday's season-ending debacle to the Giants and discuss the big decisions awaiting Jim Irsay this offseason. Also, the latest on the Pacers, who have gotten their season back on track, and Derek drops the ball big time while blaming it on the holidays.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 216 - 12.17.24: Colts implode in Denver, what's next for Chris Ballard, a helpful Pacers reset! 1:00:01

12M ago1:00:01

1:00:01

Derek is at an undisclosed location due to a stomach bug, but that doesn't prevent the guys from talking about the latest December Colts' playoff hopes implosion. Plus, what's the future for Chris Ballard, a hoops roundup (signs of life for the Pacers?), and TMI about Derek's illness.By Query & Schultz

1
Episode 215 - 12.10.24: IU vs. Notre Dame playoff thoughts, Colts face must-win in Denver, bad news Pacers 1:05:01

12M ago1:05:01

1:05:01

The guys lead off with the epic, all-Indiana battle between IU and Notre Dame to begin the first ever 12-team College Football Playoff. Also, the Colts face a virtual must-win in Denver coming off the bye, why the Pacers aren't worth your time right now, and Jake shares his first Silent Night experience at Taylor University.…