Best MVPAndy Podcasts (2025)

1
S2. Episode 22: Unsolved Disappearance: Sherry Lynn Marler 0:18

Play Pause

1+ y ago0:18

0:18

This week Tiffany threw the dart and it landed on Alabama! Join us while we discuss the mysterious disappearance of Sherry Lynn Marler. Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 21: Unsolved Murder and Crime: Nicole Aguilera and The Amtrak Sunset Limited 27:55

1+ y ago27:55

27:55

This week, Andy threw the dart and it landed on Arizona. Join us while we discuss the puzzling circumstances of Nicole Aguilera’s case and the derailment of the Amtrak Sunset Limited. Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 20: Unsolved Murders: Margaret Sweet and RJ Lockwood 46:14

1+ y ago46:14

46:14

This week, Unsolved America returns to discuss some holiday mysteries! In this special episode, Andy and Tiff both share stories one from Christmas Eve and the other from New Years Eve. Join us while we discuss the tragic murders of Margaret Sweet and RJ Lockwood.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 19: Unsolved Death: Natalie Wood 21:29

2y ago21:29

21:29

This week, Andy threw the dart and it landed on California! Join us while we discuss the mysterious death of Hollywood actress Natalie Wood. Was there a third person on the boat, or was she the victim of a bizarre accident?By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 18: Unsolved Murder: Las Cruces Bowling Alley Massacre 17:14

2y ago17:14

17:14

This week, Tiffany threw the dart and it landed on New Mexico. Join us while we discuss the details of the massacre that took place in the morning at a Las Cruces bowling alley.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 17: Unsolved Phenomenon: The Bell Witch 18:23

2y ago18:23

18:23

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Tennessee! Join us while we talk about these bizarre occurrences on a Tennessee family’s land in the 1800’s.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 16: Unsolved Murders: The Short Family 16:33

2y ago16:33

16:33

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed n Virginia! Join us while we discuss the mysterious murders of The Short Family.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 15: Unsolved Murders: The Killing Fields 16:37

2y ago16:37

16:37

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Texas! Join us while we discuss the discovery of multiple victims in a rural field in League City.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 14: Unsolved Mystery: Georgia Guidestones 20:08

2y ago20:08

20:08

This week Tiffany threw the dart and it landed on Georgia! Join us while we discuss the overall mystery of the Georgia Guidestones. Who was the man that had this monument commissioned, what happened to the time capsule that was supposed to be buried at the sight, and what did the guidestones really stand for?…

1
S2. Episode 13: Unsolved Phenomenon: The Exorcism of Roland Doe 20:01

2y ago20:01

20:01

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Missouri! Join us while we discuss the real life events that inspired a classic horror movie!By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 12: Unsolved Phenomenon: The Little Green Men 14:50

2y ago14:50

14:50

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Kentucky! Join us while we learn about the time some little green men invaded a small town in Kentucky!By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 11: Unsolved Disappearance: Helen Voorhees Brach 25:52

2y ago25:52

25:52

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Illinois! Join us while we discuss the mysterious disappearance of the candy heiress Helen Voorhees Brach.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 10: Unsolved Murder: Kurt Sova 16:47

2+ y ago16:47

16:47

This week, Andy threw the dart and it landed on Ohio! Join us while we discuss the strange disappearance and murder of Kurt Sova.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 9: Unsolved Murder: Patricia Webb 20:56

2+ y ago20:56

20:56

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Nebraska! Join us while we discuss the bizarre murder of Patricia Webb.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 8: Unsolved Disappearance: William Ebeneezer Jones Jr. 16:18

2+ y ago16:18

16:18

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on New Jersey! Join us while we discuss the mysterious disappearance of William Ebeneezer Jones Jr.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 7: Unsolved Phenomenon: Bigfoot 26:57

2+ y ago26:57

26:57

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Washington! Join us while we dive into Bigfoot sightings of the Pacific Northwest.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 6: Unsolved Phenomenon: Fouke Monster 21:03

2+ y ago21:03

21:03

This week, Tiffany threw the dart and it landed on Arkansas! Join us while we discuss the mysterious sightings of the Fouke Monster, a cryptid that has lowkey been seen several times throughout history.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 5: Unsolved Murder: Terry Brisk 24:32

2+ y ago24:32

24:32

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Minnesota! Join us while we discuss the bizarre murder of Terry Brisk while he was hunting on his family’s property.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 4: Unsolved Murder: Suzanne Jovin 26:30

2+ y ago26:30

26:30

This week, Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Connecticut! Join us while we discuss the murder and wildly frustrating investigation of Suzanne Jovin. Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 3: Unsolved Disappearance: Michael Bryson 19:11

2+ y ago19:11

19:11

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Oregon. Join us while we discuss the puzzling disappearance of Michael Bryson.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 2: Unsolved Murder: Rita Bouchard 24:22

2+ y ago24:22

24:22

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Rhode Island. Join us while we discuss the bizarre murder of Rita Bouchard.By Andy and Tiffany

1
S2. Episode 1: Unsolved Disappearance: Dail Dinwiddie 15:37

2+ y ago15:37

15:37

Welcome to season 2 of Unsolved America! This week, Andy threw the dart and it landed on South Carolina. Join us while we discuss the disappearance of Dail Dinwiddie.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 53: Unsolved Disappearance: The Sodder Children Pt. 2 20:41

3y ago20:41

20:41

This week, we continue the story of the missing Sodder children! If you haven’t caught the first part, turn around and go back to Episode 52. Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 52: Unsolved Disappearance: The Sodder Children Pt. 1 20:39

3y ago20:39

20:39

This week, Andy threw the dart and it landed on West Virginia! Join us while we discuss the bizarre events that took place on Christmas Eve in Fayetteville, West Virginia. This episode has been split into two episodes, tune in next week for the conclusion to this mystery!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 51: Unsolved Disappearance: Erica Fraysure 17:04

3y ago17:04

17:04

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Kentucky! Join us while we discuss the bizarre disappearance of teenager Erica Fraysure.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 50: Unsolved Disappearance: Hang Lee 16:36

3y ago16:36

16:36

This week! Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Minnesota! Join us while we dive into this unsolved case that includes several different stories from a single eye witness!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 49: Unsolved Disappearance: David Ortiz Jr 18:37

3y ago18:37

18:37

This week, Andy threw the dart and it landed on New Mexico! Join us while Andy explains the random disappearance of David Ortiz, Jr! What happened to David on Halloween night in 2010?By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 48: Unsolved Phenomenon: Dwayyo aka Maryland's Werewolf 17:37

3y ago17:37

17:37

This week, Tiff through the dart and it landed on Maryland! Join us while we discuss the strange and mysterious siting of the Dwayyo, a werewolf like creature that has been seen throughout the decades in Maryland.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 47: Unsolved Phenomenon: The Van Meter Visitor 20:37

3y ago20:37

20:37

This week Andy landed on Iowa! Join us while we discuss the bizarre events from the early 1900’s that involved a mysterious creature known as The Van Meter Visitor.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 46: Unsolved Murder: Amon Jamiel 24:39

3y ago24:39

24:39

This week Tiff “threw the dart” and it “landed” on Rhode Island! Join us while we discuss the mysterious death of Amon Jamiel! Was it a disgruntled family member or was it even his own son? Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 45: Unsolved Murder: Jeannette DePalma 18:40

3y ago18:40

18:40

This week Andy through the dart and it landed on New Jersey! Join us while we discuss the mysterious death of Jeannette DePalma. A teenager whose body was found at the Devil’s Teeth six weeks after she went missing. Let’s Investigate!!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 44: Unsolved Phenomenon: Close Encounters in Ann Harbor 20:39

3y ago20:39

20:39

This week, Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Michigan! Join while we discuss the crazy close encounters in Washtenaw County. Was it really alien spaceships or was it simply swamp gas? Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 43: Unsolved Phenomenon: The Bennington Triangle 22:12

3y ago22:12

22:12

This week Andy landed on Vermont! Join us while we discuss The Bennington Triangle and all of the odd phenomenon in this area. A plethora of people go missing on one particular mountain, is it a benevolent spirit or man eating rocks? Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 42: Unsolved Murders: The Sims Family 20:21

3y ago20:21

20:21

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Florida! Join us while we discuss the unsolved murders of the Sims family. Let’s Investigate!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 41: Unsolved Murder: Sylvia Baker 22:58

3y ago22:58

22:58

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Connecticut! Join us while we discuss the bizarre murder of Sylvia Baker. Was it possibly connected an unknown serial killer?By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 40: Unsolved Phenomenon: Winchester Mystery House 33:39

3y ago33:39

33:39

This week, Tiff threw the dart and it landed on California! Join us while we discuss the bizarre property popularly known as the Winchester Mystery House!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 39: Unsolved Disappearance: Jacqueline Levitz 26:37

3y ago26:37

26:37

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Mississippi! Join us while we discuss the bizarre disappearance of Jacqueline Levitz!By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 38: Unsolved Murder: Lisa Au 23:59

3y ago23:59

23:59

This week Tiffany landed on Hawaii! Join us while we discuss the mysterious disappearance and murder of Lisa Au.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 37: Unsolved Mystery: Phantom Whistler 22:13

3y ago22:13

22:13

This week, Andy landed on Louisiana and discusses the stalking phantom whistler that terrorized Jacqueline Cadow in the 1950s. We then briefly discuss the unsolved disappearance of AJ Breaux.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 36: Unsolved Phenomenon: Settlement at Quindaro 22:31

3y ago22:31

22:31

This week Tiffany threw the dart and it landed on Kansas! Join us while we discuss the seemingly murderous phenomenon at one residence in particular near the Settlement at Quindaro.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 35: Unsolved Murders: Suellen Evans and Brenda Joyce Holland 22:39

3y ago22:39

22:39

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on North Carolina! Join us while we discuss the 1965 murder of Suellen Evans and the 1965 Murder of Breda Joyce Holland. Although they are not related, both cases have gone cold.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 34: Unsolved Phenomenon: The Bridgewater Triangle 30:37

3+ y ago30:37

30:37

This week Tiff landed on Massachusetts! Join us while we discuss the unsolved phenomenon that takes place within The Bridgewater Triangle.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 33: Unsolved Phenomenon: Mel's Hole and Star Jelly 23:13

3+ y ago23:13

23:13

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Washington! Join us as we discuss the mysterious abilities of Mel’s Hole and the gelatinous orbs that fell from the sky and made one town sick.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 32: Unsolved Disappearance: Jeremy Grice 23:04

3+ y ago23:04

23:04

This week Tiff threw the dart and it landed on South Carolina! Join us while we discuss the bizarre disappearance of 4 year old Jeremy Grice.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 31: Unsolved Disappearance: Relisha Rudd 25:38

3+ y ago25:38

25:38

This week Andy threw the dart and landed on Washington D.C.! Join us while we discuss the bizarre disappearance of 8-year-old Relisha Rudd.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 30: Unsolved Murders: Cowden Family 23:58

3+ y ago23:58

23:58

This week, Tiff threw the dart and it landed on Oregon. Join us while we discuss the unsolved murder of the Cowden Family.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 29: Unsolved Murder: Melissa Witt 17:34

3+ y ago17:34

17:34

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Arkansas. Join us while we discuss the unsolved murder of Melissa Witt.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 28: Unsolved Murder: Annie Korynta 19:05

3+ y ago19:05

19:05

This week, Tiff landed on North Dakota! Join us while we discuss the disturbing murder of Annie Korynta.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 27: Unsolved Disappearance: Kurt Newton 22:55

3+ y ago22:55

22:55

This week Andy threw the dart and it landed on Maine! Join us while we discuss the unsolved disappearance of Kurt Newton.By Andy and Tiffany

1
Episode 26: Unsolved Phenomenon: Georgia Rudolph 27:04

3+ y ago27:04

27:04

This week Tiffany through the dart and it landed on Ohio! Join us as we discuss the visions of a past life that haunted Georgia Rudolph.By Andy and Tiffany