Best Nostalgia Bomb Podcasts (2025)

1
Episode 172: Sonic Temple 2025 Breakdown: A Metalhead's Paradise 1:16:31

1d ago1:16:31

1:16:31

Metal mayhem and festival tales dominate as we break down the Sonic Temple experience from start to finish. After four years of podcasting (an eternity in the podcast world!), we're celebrating episode 172 with a deep dive into what makes a great metal festival. Sonic Temple emerges as the clear winner when compared to Inkcarceration, offering flat…

1
Colonization: Preparations 7:43

4d ago7:43

7:43

Tarian and his closest advisors stood atop the wall, staring out at the horde of alien creatures massing below. Through his telescope, he spotted trolls, goblins, and new, even more terrifying creatures. He lowered the scope, looked over his shoulder, and addressed his advisors. "Kel, there's more of them than last time." Keldon reached out, and Ta…

1
Episode 171: Sonic Temple 2025 Preview 1:13:26

8d ago1:13:26

1:13:26

Ready your eardrums for a wild ride through the Sonic Temple Music Festival lineup! In this episode, we transform into musical explorers, diving headfirst into the unknown bands populating the four-day metal extravaganza in Columbus. Before our musical journey begins, we spend some quality time geeking out over HBO's "Righteous Gemstones," apprecia…

1
Colonization: Allies 7:35

11d ago7:35

7:35

Tarian marched through the dense forest, his detachment trailing behind. Upon entering a small clearing, Tarian retrieved his radio. “Everyone on me, I’ve found a clearing, and I want to regroup.” As a series of confirmations rang out, he switched his radio to another channel as he leaned against a tree. “Kel, has your team found anything...…

1
Episode 170: We ranked our top Disney movies! Plus much more! 1:11:43

16d ago1:11:43

1:11:43

Remember when you and your friends would spend hours debating the best Disney movies before cranking up some heavy metal? That's exactly the vibe we deliver in this latest episode of It's Everyday with John and Jay. We kick things off with an epic Disney discussion, ranking our top five animated classics. Robin Hood claims Jay's number one spot, wh…

1
Colonization: Assault on the Walls 7:35

18d ago7:35

7:35

Tarian stood atop the partially constructed walls as his gaze swept across the writhing mass of monsters. As he surveyed a source of his nightmares, he rubbed his brow when he recognized...By Steven Meehan

1
Episode 169: The Great Candy and Restaurant Debate 1:21:25

20d ago1:21:25

1:21:25

Dive into the hilarious, unfiltered world of John and Jay as they tackle everything from post-Easter reflections to passionate metal music discoveries in this episode that feels like hanging out with your most entertaining friends. The conversation kicks off with lighthearted "Zombie Jesus Day" greetings before evolving into what might be the most …

1
The Last Resort 7:29

25d ago7:29

7:29

A scouting squadron, responsible for finding safety, found it moored to the coast like a forgotten legend, scarred and silent, yet still afloat. A seemingly operable battleship, untouched by conflict or the passage of time. They hoped the vessel would be their chance to escape the dying world. Although it appeared safe, the fear of humanity’s bane …

1
Episode 168: Comedy, Chaos, and Pop Culture: Exploring Metal, Movies, and Random Bullshit 1:08:29

30d ago1:08:29

1:08:29

Take a wild ride through the chaotic minds of John and Jay as they navigate everything from indie horror films to metal music breakdowns in this unfiltered exploration of pop culture's strangest corners. The hosts kick off with an enthusiastic analysis of "Finley," a short horror film featuring a hilariously incompetent killer puppet who struggles …

1
Colonization: The Missing 7:32

1M ago7:32

7:32

Keldon brought his radio to his mouth as he walked up the hill. "Tarian, there's no sign of the missing colonists yet, and we've covered most of this sector." Over the radio, Tarian's voice crackled with a mix of frustration and weariness. "Kel, during the last few months, we've dealt with everything from giant wolves to dragons...…

1
Episode 167: The Trials and Tribulations of an Aspiring Rapper Named Skiddles. 1:07:31

1M ago1:07:31

1:07:31

Ever wondered what happens when a painfully awkward aspiring rapper named Skiddles visits a comedy podcast? Prepare yourself for one of our most bizarre and hilarious episodes yet. Skiddles—who claims to be "from the depths of hell" but is actually from northeastern Ohio—joins us in studio to showcase his questionable freestyle skills over AI-gener…

1
Colonization: Exploration of Morven 7:41

1M ago7:41

7:41

With his back resting against a tree, Tarian held his canteen between his knees as he stared at the hull of the colonization ship. His gaze drifted to the gash running behind the metal carcass, and he drew in a breath as his eyes closed, expelling a tear. Lucinda stepped beside Tarian and leaned against the same tree...…

1
Episode 166: Fat Strip Clubs & The Gabagool Gals 1:21:08

1M ago1:21:08

1:21:08

Have you ever been laughing so hard in the shower that you had to tell Alexa to pause the podcast? That's exactly what happened to Jay this week while listening to our own show—a testament to the unpredictable hilarity that unfolds when we hit record. This episode takes you on a journey through our weekend adventures, starting with Jay's experience…

1
Colonization: Landing on Morven 7:48

2M ago7:48

7:48

Tarian drew a deep breath as he peered through the colonization ship's windshield. He rested his fingers on the hull as he turned toward the other individuals on the bridge, Keldon and Sherry. With a soft smile, Tarian sauntered to Sherry's seat and touched the top of one of her screens. "Can you confirm if the planet is capable of supporting life.…

1
Episode 165: Small Town Laughs: Weight Loss, Wrestling, and Controversial Dreams 1:09:09

2M ago1:09:09

1:09:09

Two friends with absolutely no filter take you on a wild conversational journey through the everyday absurdities of life in small-town Ohio. This episode captures John and Jay at their uncensored best as they navigate topics ranging from serious business ventures to uncomfortably hilarious personal stories. John shares his ambitious journey toward …

1
Bombing Run 8:01

2M ago8:01

8:01

...The navigator asked while she referenced her map. The pilot’s fingers tightened around the steering yoke as he inquired, “Aside from us being at war?” “Their aircraft aren’t as advanced as ours, Erik,” she said, leaning into her seat. The young woman pulled her legs onto the edge of the chair, wrapping them up with her arms. “True,” Erik hedged.…

1
Episode 164: From Happy Gilmore to Gunther: A Chaotic Journey Through Pop Culture 1:13:50

2M ago1:13:50

1:13:50

Ready for a rollercoaster ride through the weird, wonderful, and occasionally NSFW corners of pop culture? Buckle up as this episode takes you on a lightning-fast journey across wildly diverse topics that somehow all connect through the hosts' infectious enthusiasm and unfiltered commentary. The Happy Gilmore 2 trailer serves as our jumping-off poi…

1
Draconic Bargain 7:41

2M ago7:41

7:41

While a gnarled man with wild white hair walked in front of his bookshelf, his finger traced the spine of each book on the fifth shelf from the floor. When he felt the one constructed with dragon scales, he stopped and grinned. He pulled the volume from its fellows and clutched it to his chest, marching for the table in the middle of the room. “Sem…

1
Episode 163: Weight Loss Journeys, F-Bombs & Swedish Metal 1:14:26

2M ago1:14:26

1:14:26

"You like racy shit, you like problems going on? You like sexual misconduct? You're in the right f***ing place." With this bold introduction, John and Jay set the tone for another unfiltered journey through their world where nothing is off-limits. What begins as a birthday celebration for John quickly evolves into a poignant reflection on shared bi…

1
The Grave Countdown 7:21

2M ago7:21

7:21

Pausing backstage, Ryan pulled the bagged letter out of his coat. Forensics had examined the thing already, but he never wanted to contaminate the evidence. He quickly reread the mismatched letters, yearning for some new insight. Unfortunately, it revealed nothing new. Ryan considered the morning’s private courier delivery to the station. However, …

1
Episode 162: Eurotrip: A Musical Journey Through Eurovision 2025...Yes..More Music!! 1:11:33

2M ago1:11:33

1:11:33

Ready for a musical adventure that spans continents, genres, and internet rabbit holes? Join John and Jay as they plunge headfirst into the weird and wonderful world of Eurovision 2025, sampling entries from across Europe that range from hypnotic techno bangers to emotional ballads. The journey begins with a hilarious exploration of "Brody Quest," …

1
Dueling Wizards 7:40

2M ago7:40

7:40

A blue incandescent light wrapped around the fleeing mage’s hand, forming a crackling sphere of energy. With a grunt, he threw the magical ball at his pursuer. However, the second man in flight plucked it from its path and tossed it into the sky. As it rushed toward the stars, it exploded, resulting in an explosion of concentric azure rings filling…

1
Episode 161: Internationally Known...Domestically Infamous...John and Jay 1:14:29

3M ago1:14:29

1:14:29

What happens when two unfiltered friends discover a Norwegian film about a man in a dog costume? Pure podcast magic. Our conversation takes a deep dive into "Good Boy," a disturbing psychological thriller that left us equally fascinated and disturbed – complete with a twist ending that transforms it from quirky to horrifying in seconds. We're celeb…

1
Downpour 7:40

3M ago7:40

7:40

As Amelia’s feet carried her forward, she tugged at her hood to keep the chilly air from overpowering her. But when she stepped onto a slick patch of earth, her foot slid, causing her to stumble. After she hit the ground, she propped herself up and ran a finger through the muddy surface. She rubbed the mud between her fingers before standing up and…

1
Episode 160: The Misadventures of Everyday Life: A Comedy Special! 1:05:45

3M ago1:05:45

1:05:45

Immerse yourself in a laugh-filled journey through the latest episode of "It's Every Day with John and Jay." This week, the hosts unpack a range of relatable topics that span from the intricate challenges of navigating modern workplace dynamics to reminiscing about transformative family vacations. Highlighting the emotional burdens witnessed in the…

1
Junkyard Hunt 7:21

3M ago7:21

7:21

A pair of rough hands slammed into Lucas’s swaying back, driving him to the ground amidst the skeletonized vehicles and scattered debris. He rolled over and stared up into the sun, blinking as it beat down upon him. Despite his scattered mind, Lucas caught sight of his assailant squatting beside him, licking his lips...…

1
Episode 159: Vintage Finds and A Whimsical Chat with Special Guest President Donald J. Trump 1:19:43

3M ago1:19:43

1:19:43

What happens when you mix the excitement of an Ohio Stadium VIP tour with the nostalgic charm of Notre Dame's campus and a newfound obsession with online auctions? You get a whirlwind episode filled with laughter, unexpected adventures, and a few lessons learned. We kick off with a hilarious post office story involving an Ohio State hat and take yo…

1
Reflections 7:45

3M ago7:45

7:45

With a sigh, Lucious withdrew something from his pocket before re-reading it. Come to the local museum. Tonight, by six, locate the trio of paintings featuring a mother and child, then settle onto the nearby couch. Lucious glanced at his watch as he ran his fingers through his hair, ignoring the bald spot. “Fifteen minutes early.” He crushed the no…

1
Episode 158: Scandalous Escapades Unveiled // Techno-Metal Delights 1:08:13

3M ago1:08:13

1:08:13

Ever wondered what happens when a podcast kicks off with a bit of scandalous intrigue? Get ready for laughter and surprises as we open with a tantalizing teaser of a recent escapade that sets the stage for an evening filled with candid humor and nostalgia. We dive into John's dedication to fitness, his progress becoming a beacon of inspiration, and…

1
The Noodle Trap 7:06

3M ago7:06

7:06

One day a father and his daughter were out eating at their favorite restaurant, The Noodle Shop. The father enjoyed that he got the night off from cooking, while his daughter enjoyed her macaroni and cheese. As always they got their meal and went to their regular booth to enjoy their dinner together. Unfortunately, this night was about to change. A…

1
Episode 157: Techno Tunes and AI Creations Collide in a Musical Adventure! 1:06:19

4M ago1:06:19

1:06:19

Craving a techno beat to spice up your podcast intros? We've got you covered! Our escapades with AI in creating a techno-metal fusion intro are as unpredictable as securing that must-have item from GameStop. Discover our love for Electric Cowboy's latest earworm and our amusing speculations about their Eurovision potential. The fun doesn't stop wit…

1
Birthday Blowout 7:28

4M ago7:28

7:28

Wrapping her hands around Damien, Jasmine asked, “Are you excited about the movie?” “I am,” he replied as he broke her grip, “I was worried that you were going to be late.” “It’s my birthday, and you didn’t wait outside for me. Just because you had your own ticket…” Jasmine teased with a grin. Her hand absently brushed against her pendant as she co…

1
Seeking Justice 7:59

4M ago7:59

7:59

As the limousine drew to a stop, Kyle stepped in front of the vehicle, slapping the hood with a file folder. The driver’s window lowered, and he popped his head through the opening. “Are you aware of who I’m driving?” Kyle tapped the packet against his forehead as his lips curled into a grin. “I trust Chase Heath is nestled in there.” He thrust the…

1
Siphoning the Stone 8:00

4M ago8:00

8:00

Taitha’s silk shawl whipped behind her as she walked down the street. When she came to a particular building, she halted, turning to face the entrance and grinned. With a glance to each side, she stepped up to the doors, touching the clasp on her belt, and strode through the thick wooden panels. Once inside, she hurried to the map of the interior. …

1
Letters 7:13

4M ago7:13

7:13

Patricia’s fingers caressed the photograph in the album. Her fingers kept tracing James’s close-cropped brown hair. As Patricia ran her finger across the cheek on the image, she stifled a sob. Wincing under the scrutiny of James’s warm eyes, she buried her face into the album, struggling to restrain her tears. When she calmed her sorrowful eyes, Pa…

1
Episode 156: Ohio State Triumph // NIL Deals Transform the Game! 1:10:08

4M ago1:10:08

1:10:08

This episode encapsulates the joyful chaos of being an Ohio State football fan, celebrating their national championship win while reflecting on the emotional and humorous aspects of dedicated fandom. The hosts illuminate the evolving landscape of college sports, sharing heartfelt anecdotes, opinions on NIL regulations, and cherished memories from g…

1
Episode 155: Restaurant Rankings Bonanza!! 1:18:23

4M ago1:18:23

1:18:23

Ever had a hilarious nickname stick, like Mr. Schnitzel from Walmart? Join me on this solo escapade as we navigate through a rollercoaster of anecdotes, including a side-splitting McDonald's misadventure with Isaac Best and Oush Fitness. We tackle the quirks of modern fast-food dynamics, especially the perils of self-entitlement in the workforce. A…

1
Journey of Thanks 7:20

4M ago7:20

7:20

Tully glanced down at his hand and reviewed the note that was firmly attached to his palm. The shade stared at the elegant text, yet the memory of his death snagged his focus. While it was hazy, he knew he’d attempted to save a little girl’s life. The only other solid aspect of his memory was the crushing coldness as the underwater current pulled h…

1
Episode 154: Snowstorms, Bottlegate Blunders and Retro Game Revelations! 1:07:59

4M ago1:07:59

1:07:59

Snowstorms in Ohio? They're a blessing in disguise—no alligators and hurricanes to worry about! Join us as we laugh through the chilly chaos and recount some hilarious editing blunders, including a segment that was so off-the-wall it had to be axed. We’re buzzing with excitement about our upcoming plans, featuring a potential guest appearance and a…

1
Episode 153: White Elephant Escapades // Parody Porn and Bitcoin Blackjack Madness! 1:08:26

4M ago1:08:26

1:08:26

Ever wonder how a holiday gift exchange can result in a giant wrapped shelf and endless laughter? Kick off the festive season with us as we share our quirky gift hauls and debate the chaos of white elephant gift exchanges. With tales of "Bezo Bucks," record players, and Ohio State-themed scotch glasses, our lighthearted banter will have you reminis…

1
Episode 152: Survival of the Wet Bandits & Inappropriate Holiday Tunes! 1:15:47

5M ago1:15:47

1:15:47

We’re taking a detour down memory lane with tales from our Christmas parties and family gatherings that double as epic fantasy league meetings, all while dropping pop culture gems like it’s our day job. Have you ever wondered how much beating the Wet Bandits from Home Alone could realistically sustain? We dissect the improbable survival of Harry an…

1
Episode 151: Fantasy Football Semifinal Shenanigans // Karate Kid Comebacks and a Macaulay Culkin Misadventure! 1:20:03

5M ago1:20:03

1:20:03

Ever wondered what happens when your fantasy football strategy feels like a scene from an old EA Sports game? Join us, John and Jay, as we ride the emotional rollercoaster of reaching the semifinals in our fantasy league. Our conversation spins from the joy of unexpected player performances to the more serious side of college sports, tackling the c…

1
Episode 150: Cleveland Adventures & College Football Fiascos // Reliving Disney Magic and Vinyl's Warm Embrace! 1:11:59

5M ago1:11:59

1:11:59

Ever wondered what happens when nostalgia meets a night out? Join us as we recount our latest whirlwind adventure in downtown Cleveland, filled with laughter, spicy appetizers, and unexpected blasts from the past. Jay gets the party started with tales of his culinary curiosity and a surprise reconnection with an old contact. Meanwhile, John weighs …

1
Episode 149: Ohio State vs. Michigan // Witness the 5 Stages of Grief in One Sitting! 1:15:44

5M ago1:15:44

1:15:44

What happens when Ohio State fans grapple with the harsh sting of a rivalry disappointment, coupled with a rollercoaster of emotions and comedic banter? We kick things off by diving into the aftermath of Ohio State's devastating loss to Michigan, which left us questioning everything from the play calling to conspiracy theories about the kicker's pe…

1
Episode 148: Turkey Pranks and Embarrassing Black Friday T-shirts // Rock Legends Revisited 1:15:52

6M ago1:15:52

1:15:52

What if Alexa finally understood our podcast? Join us for a hilarious episode where we turn virtual assistant struggles into comedic gold and share our unorthodox Black Friday tradition of swapping the most embarrassing shirts ever. Thanksgiving's turkey gets a brutal critique as we laugh over family hijinks, all while reminiscing about rock concer…

1
Episode 147 Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul // A Comedy of Errors and Unexpected Laughs Plus Special Guest Kaydence! 1:17:49

6M ago1:17:49

1:17:49

Imagine tuning into a highly anticipated fight, only to find yourself watching it on Twitter because Netflix took a dive. That's exactly what happened when the Mike Tyson vs. Jake Paul event turned into a comedy of errors and unexpected laughs. Our latest episode kicks off with this wild story as we navigate the chaos of point deductions and an unf…

1
Episode 146: A new era has begun! It's Everyday with John and Jay! 1:08:03

6M ago1:08:03

1:08:03

It's a new day yes it is! Welcome to a new era of this podcast. We are now "It's Everyday with John and Jay". A no holds barred comedy podcast that isn't afraid of pushing a few buttons. A true "shoot the shit" show with hilarious banter you've grown to love. Send us a text message and let us know how awesome we are! (Click the link)! Support the s…

1
Episode 145: The Green Mile (1999) // I'm so tired boss... 1:06:40

6M ago1:06:40

1:06:40

We’re stepping back to 1999 to revisit The Green Mile, the unforgettable Stephen King adaptation that captured hearts and minds with its blend of supernatural mystery and human compassion. Join us as we explore the powerful performances of Tom Hanks, Michael Clarke Duncan, and the entire cast, who brought this intense, emotional story to life. We’l…

1
Episode 144: Stand By Me (1986) // Coming-of-age Classic! 1:11:57

7M ago1:11:57

1:11:57

This week we revisit Stand By Me, Rob Reiner’s 1986 classic that captures the bittersweet magic of childhood friendships and coming-of-age in small-town America. Based on Stephen King’s novella The Body, Stand By Me tells the story of four boys on a journey to find a missing boy’s body, and in the process, they discover more about themselves and ea…

1
Episode 143: The Craft (1996) // Oh, he's sorry, he's sorry, he's sorry, he's sorry... 1:16:08

7M ago1:16:08

1:16:08

In this spellbinding episode of Back in the Day with John and Jay, we revisit The Craft, the 1996 cult classic that brought witchcraft and teenage rebellion to the big screen. Join us as we delve into the film’s edgy portrayal of high school life, friendship, and the darker side of magic, celebrating The Craft as an iconic staple of ‘90s cinema. We…

Podcasts Worth a Listen

Nostalgia Bomb Podcasts

Podcasts Worth a Listen