Best Unsolved Mysteries Rewind Podcasts (2025)

1
Moon Bases, Music & Monsters - The Paranormal 60 News 1:07:04

Play Pause

2d ago1:07:04

1:07:04

In the heart of Egypt, a 4,000-year-old artifact vanishes—from a tomb said to be cursed. On a lonely highway, a driver swears a Chupacabra ran into his headlights before everything went black. Deep in the Texas dark, something half man, half beast prowls the parks of San Antonio. Man and the Moon may have ancient ties to our civilization. From anci…

1
There's Something Out There, Probably - Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:05:47

3d ago1:05:47

1:05:47

A strange shadow overhead. An odd alliance between weird occurrences. This episode dives headfirst into the foggy world of high strangeness—where logic breaks down and the bizarre takes over. Special guest Steve Berg joins hosts Jeni Monroe & Tressa Slater with a deep love for the unexplained, and together they unpack everything from glitchy synchr…

1
Real Paranormal Stories - The Paranormal 60 1:04:34

4d ago1:04:34

1:04:34

A whisper from the floorboards. A ghostly vision in your rearview mirror. A child frozen mid-sentence as the world stops around her. These aren’t stories — they’re pleas for understanding. Real encounters from listeners around the world, each one facing something they can’t explain. In this haunting episode of The Paranormal 60, Dave Schrader, with…

1
OM Backroads: Ep. 88: Echoes in Time: The iconic Molly Stark Hospital of Louisville, Ohio 33:21

5d ago33:21

33:21

Hello and welcome to another episode of Ohio Mysteries Backroads. In tonight's episode we are joined by our special guest, Maria, as we discuss the iconic tuberculosis hospital Molly Stark of Louisville, Ohio. In this episode we uncover the fascinating, eerie and often forgotten history of the Molly Stark hospital of Louisville, Ohio. Once a season…

1
The Great Ghost Hunt of 1907 – A New England Legends Podcast 19:47

5d ago19:47

19:47

In 1907, the town of Millinocket, Maine, erupted in a literal ghost hunt. After rumors spread of a haunted house on Central Street, terrified locals grabbed their guns and opened fire on shadows in the night. Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger uncover the bizarre story that made headlines and sparked a paranormal frenzy more than a century ago.The Great G…

1
The Dating Game Killer: TRUE CRIME REWIND - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 1:07:19

6d ago1:07:19

1:07:19

For your TRUE CRIME - REWIND, we revisit the Rodney Alcala: The Dating Game Killer — Charming, Deadly, and Deceptive Step into the chilling true story of Rodney Alcala, the man once known as The Dating Game Killer. By day, he was a handsome TV contestant flashing a charismatic smile; by night, he was a sadistic predator hiding in plain sight. With …

1
The Haunted Ham House – A True Hauntings Podcast 59:19

8d ago59:19

59:19

On the banks of the River Thames stands Ham House, one of England’s most haunted mansions. From ghostly figures on its grand staircases to whispers of spirits trapped in its 17th-century halls, this historic gem hides chilling secrets behind its beauty. Join Anne and Renata as they uncover the haunted history of Ham House—where elegance meets the s…

1
E.V.P.: Spirits Speak - The Paranormal 60 1:13:56

9d ago1:13:56

1:13:56

It starts with a whisper you weren’t supposed to hear. A flicker in the static. A single voice breaking through the noise—soft, distant, impossible. But what if it isn’t your imagination? What if something out there is trying to make contact? In this chilling solo edition of The Paranormal 60, Dave Schrader explores the phenomenon of E.V.P. — Elect…

1
Beasts of the Northwoods - Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:05:02

10d ago1:05:02

1:05:02

By Dave Schrader

1
This is Gonna Sound Weird - The Paranormal 60 1:04:40

11d ago1:04:40

1:04:40

By Dave Schrader

1
The Pine Tree Riot - A New England Legends Podcast 21:41

12d ago21:41

21:41

Before the Boston Tea Party, there was the Pine Tree Riot of 1772 in Weare, New Hampshire. When colonists violently rebelled against Britain’s claim to their white pine trees, they set in motion a chain of events that would spark the American Revolution. Join Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger as they uncover this little-known act of defiance that changed…

1
Death in Apartment 603: The Ellen Greenberg Case - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 50:05

12d ago50:05

50:05

In this gripping episode of Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot, Winnie dives into one of the most baffling and heartbreaking true crime cases in recent memory — the mysterious death of Ellen Greenberg. Found with 20 stab wounds, including several to the back of her neck, Ellen’s death was ruled a suicide — a conclusion that defies logic and science. Throug…

1
Ep 319: Davis and Norris 23:30

12d ago23:30

23:30

A pair of Columbus mysteriesIn this episode, we recall two of Columbus' most stubborn mysteries. The 2019 case of Tyler Davis, who vanished after walking away from his hotel in Columbus after celebrating his wife's birthday. And the 1989 murder of Yvonne Norris, who was murdered by an intruder who set fire to her home in an attempt to destroy the c…

1
Sinister Secrets of Spider Gate Cemetery – A True Hauntings Podcast 53:39

15d ago53:39

53:39

Tucked away in the woods of Massachusetts, Spider Gate Cemetery is infamous for its chilling legends. Known as a “gateway to the underworld,” this graveyard is said to echo with ghostly voices, eerie apparitions, and dark rituals. Join Anne and Renata as they unravel the sinister myths and haunted history that make Spider Gate one of New England’s …

1
Secrets, Skulls & Spirits Edition - The Paranormal 60 News 1:23:42

16d ago1:23:42

1:23:42

Cattle carved with surgical precision on a Utah ranch… a skull hidden in a traveler’s luggage bound for ritual… ancient Amazon rock art that may be more than history, but a map to the spirit world… a psychic warning ignored with terrifying consequences… a cursed brick returned in desperation… and a haunted road where ghostly hitchhikers still vanis…

1
OM Backroads Ep:63. The Cholera Cemetery of Sandusky Ohio (rebroadcast) 26:39

17d ago26:39

26:39

Hello and welcome to another episode of Ohio Mysteries Backroads. In tonight's episode author Wendy Koile joins Doug and Dan as they discuss the Cholera Cemetery of Sandusky, Ohio. In 1849, a brutal and vicious cholera epidemic swept through the nation and the growing town of Sandusky was greatly impacted. Over half the town fled in terror and the …

1
Screams in the Wilderness - Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:03:16

17d ago1:03:16

1:03:16

Something is stirring deep within the moss-draped forests and misty peaks of Olympic National Park. From vanishing hikers and eerie lights to chilling whispers in the night, this episode dives into the park’s most baffling and unsettling encounters. Join hosts Jeni Monroe and Tressa Slater as they explore firsthand accounts, local legends, and thei…

1
The Digital Séance Experience - The Paranormal 60 1:08:42

18d ago1:08:42

1:08:42

The séance table meets the digital age in this fascinating episode of The Paranormal 60 with Dave Schrader. Paranormal investigators Ron Yacovetti and Lourdes Gonzalez join Dave to uncover how spirits may be communicating through modern electronic devices — from EVPs to ITC experiments, smart speakers, and beyond. Discover the new revolution of spi…

1
The Haunted and Cursed Ruins of Ashintully - A New England Legends Podcast 21:16

19d ago21:16

21:16

High in the Berkshire Mountains, the crumbling ruins of Ashintully Mansion hold eerie secrets. Built by explorer Robb Tytus in 1910, legend says he brought home more than artifacts from Egypt—he brought a curse. Tragedy, misfortune, and ghostly tales have haunted the site ever since. Join Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger as they uncover the chilling his…

1
Tylenol on Trial: Pills, Poison & Cover-Ups - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 1:15:40

19d ago1:15:40

1:15:40

Tylenol is back in the headlines, but for completely different reasons. Let’s step back into one of America’s most chilling true crime cases—the 1982 Tylenol murders. Seven innocent people died after taking cyanide-laced Extra-Strength Tylenol, sparking nationwide panic, a historic recall, and sweeping changes in pharmaceutical safety. Decades late…

1
Shadows of Shrewsbury Prison – A True Hauntings Podcast 58:56

22d ago58:56

58:56

Few places are darker—or more haunted—than Shrewsbury Prison. Once a fortress of punishment and despair, its crumbling walls now echo with the tormented cries of prisoners who never left. Anne and Renata uncover chilling ghost stories of executions, restless inmates, and vengeful spirits that stalk its shadowy corridors. Is Shrewsbury Prison just a…

1
The Spirit of a Seance - Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:09:20

24d ago1:09:20

1:09:20

A chilling séance in a house steeped in spiritual history. In this spine-tingling episode, your hosts dive deep into the infamous Roff House—site of the 19th-century "Watseka Wonder" possession—with the team behind a daring documentary filmed during a real séance held there last year. Paranormal investigators Neal Gibbons and psychic medium DeEtte …

1
Paranormal Mysteries - The Paranormal 60 1:11:10

25d ago1:11:10

1:11:10

Step into the world of the unknown with Dave Schrader as he welcomes psychic medium Cindy Kaza and paranormal investigator Shane Pittman to discuss their brand-new TV series, Paranormal Mysteries, streaming Sept 26, 2025 on StreamBeaconTV.com Together, they share unforgettable moments from The Holzer Files, Ghosts of Devil’s Perch, and 28 Days Haun…

1
The Great Water Beast Odziozo – A New England Legends Podcast 15:51

26d ago15:51

15:51

Long before Champ, Vermont’s Lake Champlain was said to be home to Odziozo, a colossal water beast from Abenaki legend. This ancient creature is credited with shaping the lake and surrounding land—and sightings of Odziozo outnumber those of Champ. Join Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger as they boat out near Shelburne Point in search of the truth behind o…

1
The mis-Adventures of Florida Man: Sex, Spam & Shenanigans - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 1:29:27

26d ago1:29:27

1:29:27

Tonight! Join Winnie & Dave as Florida Man proves once again that meth and mass transit are a terrible mix, hijacking a sightseeing train like it’s the Polar Express from hell. Meanwhile, a freshly minted $167 million Powerball winner turns out to be a career criminal who spent more time behind bars than most bartenders. And just when you thought y…

1
Ep: 318: A pair of Lorain County mysteries 19:28

26d ago19:28

19:28

In this episode, we share two mysteries in Lorain County. The 1991 murder of 17-yer-old Angela Ayala in her own Sheffield Lake Bedroom. And the 2010 disappearance of Darla Kustra, who vanished with the exception of her severed foot. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoicesBy Evergreen Podcasts

1
The Spirits of The Seven Gables - A True Hauntings Podcast 1:00:17

29d ago1:00:17

1:00:17

Salem, Massachusetts is famous for its ghosts—and none loom larger than those said to haunt The House of the Seven Gables. In this chilling episode, Anne and Renata explore the eerie history of one of New England’s most iconic homes, uncovering tales of restless spirits, shadowy figures, and ghostly whispers that refuse to fade. Is the mansion a hi…

1
Conversations in the Dark Edition - The Paranormal 60 News 1:11:37

1M ago1:11:37

1:11:37

So many strange things, so little time. Ghosts, Monsters, Mysterious sightings. Tonight host Dave Schrader, correspondents Greg Lawson and Sweet T are here to discuss the strange and unusual. From the loss of a Bigfoot Legend to strange Alien like creatures discovered. Conversations in the Dark Edition - The Paranormal 60 News PLEASE SUPPORT THE AD…

1
Cryptids, Phantoms, & Cons - Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:00:17

1M ago1:00:17

1:00:17

Ever wonder who wrangles the weird and has a lifetime of the unusual? This episode takes you deep into the world of high strangeness—where cryptids lurk, hauntings hit hard, and the unexplained is just part of the job. Lee Kirkland has spent decades chasing the unknown, co-creating one of the biggest cryptid conventions in the country and diving he…

1
Out of Body: The Experience - Paranormal 60 1:10:04

1M ago1:10:04

1:10:04

Can your soul step outside your body and journey into realms beyond this world? In this episode of The Paranormal 60, Dave Schrader is joined by Marilynn Hughes, founder of The Out-of-Body Travel Foundation. Since 1987, Marilynn has experienced and documented thousands of out-of-body journeys and mystical encounters, authoring over 140 books and sp…

1
The Lost Pirate Treasure of Salmon Brook - A New England Legends Podcast 22:20

1M ago22:20

22:20

Hidden deep in the woods of East Granby, Connecticut, legend whispers of a pirate’s fortune worth over $300 million today. In the 1660s, Captain David Marteen sailed his ship up the Connecticut River, stashed his treasure, and vanished without a trace. Some say his gold still lies buried along Salmon Brook—guarded by the ghostly figure of the capta…

1
OM Backroads Ep:87: Vanished in Alaska, the wild tale of Wade Tackett 21:15

1M ago21:15

21:15

Hello and welcome to another episode of Ohio Mysteries Backroads. In tonight's episode we explore the strange disappearance of Wade Tackett, a 17 year old from Hillsboro, Ohio who ventured out to Alaska to work for the summer. Wade and a friend decided to take a trip in a small boat and only the friend would return. What happened next is a crazy st…

1
Unknown Number: Catfished From Within - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 50:18

1M ago50:18

50:18

Secrets, suspicion, and betrayal in a small-town cyberstalking scandal. What looked like cyberbullying at Beal City High School was actually something darker—Munchausen by proxy in the digital age. From ruined friendships and broken trust to the shocking Netflix documentary Unknown Number: The High School Catfish, we uncover how one woman weaponize…

1
The Runcorn Poltergeist - A True Hauntings Podcast 51:28

1M ago51:28

51:28

Prepare yourself for one of the most terrifying and well-documented paranormal cases in British history: The Runcorn Poltergeist. In 1952, young John Glynn Jones and his unsuspecting family became the unwilling center of a haunting so violent it shook the entire north-west of England—and the echoes of that terror are still felt today. What began wi…

1
Dark Tourism, UFO Firefights, and Time Unraveled – The Paranormal 60 News 1:19:30

1M ago1:19:30

1:19:30

From Singapore’s chilling ghost tours and abandoned hospitals, to shocking testimony about U.S. missiles bouncing off UFOs, to a bold new theory that time itself may have three dimensions—we’re bringing you the supernatural, the mysterious, and the mind-bending. This week on The Paranormal 60 News, Dave Schrader, Greg, and Sweet-T tackle some of th…

1
UFO’s, Magnets, and Megalodon- a Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:07:41

1M ago1:07:41

1:07:41

Are there UFOs at Catalina and what the heck is a Shark Cafe anyway? Incredible guest Brittany Barbieri teaches Jeni and Tressa all about ancient astronauts, underwater alien bases, and what the love of the unknown can do. UFO’s, Magnets, and Megalodon- a Monsters Lounge Podcast Find Brittany Barbieri here: @brit_investigates (professional) @the_pa…

1
Answers to the Anomalous – The Paranormal 60 1:19:46

1M ago1:19:46

1:19:46

Are UFOs, aliens, Bigfoot, and demons part of the same mystery? Could reality itself be nothing more than a simulation? Dave Schrader and medium Scott Davis respond to listener emails about the most mind-bending questions in the paranormal. From unexplained encounters to hidden connections across the supernatural spectrum, this episode explores the…

1
The Ghost Dog of Great Wass Island – A New England Legends Podcast 20:05

1M ago20:05

20:05

Off the rocky coast of Maine lies Great Wass Island, a place where tragedy and legend meet. In this episode of New England Legends, Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger chase the eerie tale of a phantom dog said to roam the shoreline. Born of a shipwreck in the mid-1800s, this ghostly hound barks and howls at passing ships, warning them of the same fate tha…

1
Rewind: The search for Amy Mihaljevic's killer (Ep 28) with James Renner 41:56

1M ago41:56

41:56

1989, 10-year-old Amy Mihaljevic was in her home in the comfortable Cleveland suburb of Bay Village when the phone rang. A man introduced himself as her mother's co-worker, and asked for her help in picking out a gift to celebrate her mother's promotion. Amy agreed. Friends who walked her to the shopping center on the appointed day were the last to…

1
Beyond the Bridge: The Delphi Murders - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 1:38:45

1M ago1:38:45

1:38:45

Delphi Murders Deep Dive | Shadow of the Bridge & The Murder Sheet In this episode of Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot, we uncover one of the most haunting true crime cases of our time — the Delphi murders. On February 14, 2017, best friends Liberty German and Abby Williams disappeared while hiking near the Monon High Bridge in Delphi, Indiana. The shock…

1
The Moaning Spirits of Mosborough Hall Hotel – A True Hauntings Podcast 1:10:39

1M ago1:10:39

1:10:39

A White Lady paces the Lord John Darcy Suite… and her cries are not of this world. Step inside the Mosborough Hall Hotel in England, where the infamous Lord John Darcy Suite is said to be haunted by the restless White Lady. Her tragic story begins in the late 1600s, when a forbidden romance with the squire ended in betrayal, murder, and the loss of…

1
Mammoth Mysteries & Red-Haired Mummies - Monsters Lounge Podcast 57:50

2M ago57:50

57:50

What do the world’s largest cave system and ancient red-haired mummies have in common? More than you’d think. In this episode we uncover the eerie legends of Mammoth Cave, from spectral miners to underground hospitals. Plus, we’re recapping a summer spent chasing conferences, weird energy, and roadside oddities—and digging into the strange, cross-c…

1
The Ghost Theorist - The Paranormal 60 1:07:21

2M ago1:07:21

1:07:21

The static crackles, the voices bleed through, and the dead refuse to stay quiet. Phil Summers, The Ghost Theorist, takes us inside his decades of paranormal investigations, from early ghost box experiments to chilling audio evidence collected in America’s most infamous haunts. Join Dave Schrader on The Paranormal 60 as we examine Phil’s life, his …

1
Richard Potter’s Final Bow – A New England Legends 21:48

2M ago21:48

21:48

Step into the world of America’s first professional magician. In this episode of New England Legends, Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger travel to Potter Place in Andover, New Hampshire, where Richard Potter—the nation’s earliest celebrity illusionist—took his final bow in 1835. Potter wasn’t just a master of sleight of hand; he was a trailblazer. A Black…

1
OM Backroads Ep:15. The Men in Black visit Ohio Rewind 14:05

2M ago14:05

14:05

We are all familiar with the Men in Black film franchise starring Tommy Lee Jones and Will Smith, but did you know that the Men in Black were a very real phenomenon often associated with Flying Saucers, especially in the 1960s and 1970s? Join Dan and Mike as they discuss the bizarre Men in Black case that was reported in Dayton, Ohio, in 1967. This…

1
Fiction to Fear, Manifestoes & Monsters - Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot 41:23

2M ago41:23

41:23

TONIGHT! Dark obsessions, hidden delusions, and the thin line between fantasy and violence—this episode of Mysteries, Mayhem & Merlot dives deep into chilling stories where imagination turned deadly. From the haunting origins of Slender Man and the brutal stabbing that shook a community, to Anne Perry’s shocking crime as a teenager, and the recent …

1
The Frights in Frankenstein’s Castle – A True Hauntings Podcast 45:00

2M ago45:00

45:00

A crumbling castle, a mad alchemist, and whispers of the dead… welcome to Frankenstein’s Castle. High on a hill in Germany stands Frankenstein’s Castle, once home to the infamous alchemist Johann Conrad Dippel—a man whose dark experiments may have inspired Mary Shelley’s legendary monster. But beyond the chilling legends, visitors report ghostly fi…

1
Ancient Secrets & Afterlife Mysteries Edition – The Paranormal 60 News 1:10:51

2M ago1:10:51

1:10:51

Ancient secrets, afterlife mysteries, and a legendary monster return—this episode of The Paranormal 60 News has it all. Join Dave Schrader, Sweet-T, and Greg as they break down the wildest headlines of the week: a man who died three times and lived to tell what he saw on the other side, the stars of The Conjuring movie series weigh in on Matt Rife …

1
Secrets in the Rectory - Monsters Lounge Podcast 1:01:47

2M ago1:01:47

1:01:47

Whispers in the dark, slamming doors with no source, and shadows that move when no one's watching—this episode dives deep into one of the Midwest’s most chilling paranormal hotspots. Our guest shares her firsthand experiences owning haunted properties, organizing large-scale investigations, and what’s in store for the upcoming exploration of the no…

1
Mysterious Places & the Future Us - The Paranormal 60 Podcast 1:06:08

2M ago1:06:08

1:06:08

A plane crash, 52 lives lost, and a forest alive with mystery. In 1965, Flight 21 exploded over British Columbia in what remains Canada’s largest unsolved mass murder. Paranormal investigator Dave Scott takes us deep into the crash site, where ghosts, UFOs, Sasquatch, and even whispers of skinwalkers haunt the wilderness. Then, researcher Mark Lano…