Instagram has just rolled out its most significant algorithm update in years, and it's changing everything businesses thought they knew about social media marketing. In this essential episode, hosts Laura, Marcus, and Gabrielle break down Instagram's revolutionary "Create Your Own Algorithm" feature and explain exactly what it means for your business's visibility, engagement, and growth strategy.

Whether you're a Belfast-based SME struggling with declining reach, a Northern Ireland business trying to understand why your content isn't performing, or a UK company looking to future-proof your Instagram strategy, this comprehensive discussion will give you the actionable insights you need to adapt and thrive.

You'll discover:

• How Instagram's AI-powered content control actually works behind the scenes
• Why the traditional "post Reels for growth" strategy is no longer enough
• The engagement hierarchy that Instagram's algorithm now prioritises (and how to leverage it)
• Practical Instagram SEO techniques to optimise your bios, captions, and alt text
• What "recycled content" penalties mean for your business and how to avoid them
• The truth about scheduling tools, banned content, and platform restrictions
• How to implement an omni-channel approach that protects your business from algorithm changes
• What 2026 will bring: deeper user-focused signals and relationship-based reach

This isn't just theory—it's practical, implementable advice from digital marketing experts who specialise in organic strategies for SMEs across Northern Ireland, Ireland, and the UK.

Understanding the New Algorithm (00:00 - 03:30)

• 00:00 – The Hidden Value of AI Browsers and how they're changing search behaviour
• 00:34 – Introduction to Instagram's groundbreaking algorithm update
• 01:03 – What "Create Your Own Algorithm" actually means for users and businesses
• 01:29 – How AI-powered content control puts users back in the driver's seat
• 02:04 – User frustration with forced recommended content and algorithmic overreach
• 02:44 – Why user-led content selection matters more than ever before
• 03:08 – Social media negativity trends vs Instagram's new positive direction
• 03:30 – The real impact of these algorithm changes on your business visibility

Instagram SEO & Visibility Strategies (03:48 - 05:46)

• 03:48 – Instagram SEO fundamentals: optimising bios, captions, and alt text for discoverability
• 04:24 – Achieving better visibility through strategic user content preferences
• 04:53 – Views vs engagement: what businesses should actually expect and measure
• 05:21 – Quality over follower count: completely rethinking performance metrics
• 05:46 – Declining attention spans and engagement fatigue: the reality check every business needs

How Instagram's Multiple Algorithms Work (06:14 - 08:37)

• 06:14 – How customised feeds dramatically improve user engagement rates
• 06:28 – Understanding that Instagram has multiple algorithms, not just one
• 07:00 – How users interact differently with Stories, Reels, and feed posts
• 07:17 – Algorithm behaviour patterns in share recommendations
• 07:43 – How Instagram learns and adapts to your specific sharing patterns
• 08:10 – What this fundamental shift means for user experience going forward
• 08:24 – How shared content between friends actively shapes your feed
• 08:37 – Instagram's ultimate goal: keeping users on the platform longer (and why that matters to you)

Business Strategy & Content Restrictions (09:12 - 12:54)

• 09:12 – How businesses should encourage meaningful user engagement
• 09:27 – Debunking misconceptions about banned or restricted content
• 09:48 – Using scheduling tools like Buffer effectively across multiple platforms
• 10:02 – Monitoring reach drops in your analytics: red flags to watch for
• 10:23 – Striking parallels with Google's algorithm updates and AI-generated content policies
• 11:04 – How Instagram is echoing Google's historical algorithm crackdowns
• 11:34 – Business frustrations around "recycled content" penalties explained
• 12:20 – Understanding that restrictions mainly affect non-followers and organic growth potential
• 12:54 – Why Reels are no longer the sole strategy for Instagram growth

Future-Proofing Your Strategy (13:12 - 16:28)

• 13:12 – The critical importance of using all types of Instagram content formats
• 14:07 – "Don't put all your eggs in one basket": the digital marketing golden rule
• 14:22 – Omni-channel marketing and building lasting brand awareness
• 14:47 – Looking ahead to 2026: Instagram's shift toward deeper user-focused signals
• 14:53 – How user relationships and past interactions will increasingly influence reach
• 15:13 – Why relevance, timing, and trending topics now matter more than ever
• 15:30 – The engagement hierarchy revealed: Shares → Saves → Comments → Likes
• 16:11 – Why responding to comments quickly boosts your algorithmic ranking
• 16:28 – Future developments and further AI integration on the horizon

If you're running an SME in Belfast, across Northern Ireland, or throughout Ireland and the UK, this algorithm update has massive implications for your digital marketing strategy. Here's why you need to pay attention:

The Local Advantage: Instagram's shift toward user relationships and past interactions means your existing customer base and local community connections are more valuable than ever. Belfast businesses with strong community ties can leverage these relationships for better organic reach without spending a penny on ads.

Cost-Effective Growth: As a region where marketing budgets are often tighter than London or other major cities, Northern Ireland businesses need organic strategies that work. Understanding these algorithm changes means you can achieve visibility without the paid advertising costs that larger competitors rely on.

AI Implementation Opportunities: ProfileTree specialises in AI training and implementation for SMEs. The AI-powered content control features Instagram is rolling out mirror the AI capabilities we help businesses implement across their entire digital presence—from Answer Engine Optimization to automated content workflows.

Omni-Channel Necessity: With Instagram's algorithm becoming less predictable, Northern Ireland businesses can't afford to rely on a single platform. This update reinforces why we advocate for diversified digital strategies that include WordPress websites, SEO, video content, and multiple social channels.

Authentic Engagement Focus: The new algorithm rewards genuine engagement over vanity metrics—perfectly suited to Northern Ireland's business culture of relationship-building and community connection. Your authentic local presence is now your competitive advantage.

For deeper insights into the topics discussed in this episode, explore these ProfileTree resources:

Instagram & Social Media Marketing:

• "Instagram Algorithm Changes 2025: What Businesses Need to Know"
• "Instagram SEO: Complete Optimisation Guide for SMEs"
• "Social Media Marketing Without Paid Ads: Organic Strategies That Work"
• "Reels vs Stories vs Posts: Which Instagram Format Drives Results?"
• "Content Scheduling Tools: Comprehensive Review for UK Businesses"

Algorithm & SEO Strategy:

• "Google Algorithm Updates and What They Mean for Social Media"
• "Answer Engine Optimization: The Future of Digital Marketing"
• "AI-Generated Content: Quality Standards for 2025"
• "Engagement Metrics That Actually Matter for Business Growth"
• "Omni-Channel Marketing Strategy for Northern Ireland SMEs"

Digital Marketing Fundamentals:

• "Why Belfast Businesses Are Ditching Paid Ads for Organic Strategies"
• "Building Brand Awareness on a Budget: A Northern Ireland Guide"
• "Digital Marketing Mistakes Every SME Should Avoid"
• "Quality vs Quantity: Rethinking Social Media Performance"
• "Future-Proofing Your Digital Presence: 2026 and Beyond"

Visit profiletree.com to access our complete library of guides, case studies, and training resources designed specifically for SMEs.

Who We Are: ProfileTree is Northern Ireland's leading digital marketing agency, specialising in organic growth strategies, AI implementation, and comprehensive training for SMEs. Based at the McSweeney Centre in Belfast (31 Henry Place, Belfast BT15 2AY), we serve businesses throughout Northern Ireland, Ireland, and the UK who want to achieve sustainable digital growth without relying on expensive paid advertising.

What We Offer:

WordPress Web Design & Development

• Custom, conversion-focused WordPress websites designed for SME budgets
• Mobile-responsive designs optimised for user experience and search engines
• E-commerce solutions built for growth
• Ongoing website maintenance and security
• Website training so you can manage your own content confidently

Search Engine Optimisation (SEO)

• Technical SEO audits and implementation
• Local SEO for Belfast and Northern Ireland businesses
• Keyword research and content strategy
• Link building through authentic relationship development
• Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) for AI-powered search platforms
• Ongoing SEO training and consultancy

AI Training & Implementation

• Practical AI tools training for marketing teams
• AI workflow integration for content creation and customer service
• Custom AI solution implementation for SME operations
• ChatGPT, Claude, and other AI platform training
• AI strategy development tailored to your business goals
• Ongoing support and updates as AI technology evolves

Video Production & Content Creation

• Professional video content for websites, social media, and YouTube
• Podcast recording and production
• Product demonstration videos
• Customer testimonial filming
• Educational content creation
• Video SEO optimisation

Digital Marketing Strategy

• Comprehensive digital marketing audits
• Omni-channel marketing strategy development
• Social media strategy (Instagram, TikTok, Facebook, LinkedIn, X, Pinterest)
• Content marketing planning and execution
• Email marketing strategy
• Analytics setup and interpretation training

What We DON'T Offer:

• Paid advertising management (Google Ads, Facebook Ads, etc.)
• Short-term "quick fix" solutions that don't deliver lasting results
• One-size-fits-all packages that ignore your specific business needs
• Black-hat SEO tactics that risk penalties
• Services that create dependency rather than empowering your team

Why Choose ProfileTree:

1. Organic-First Philosophy: We don't touch paid ads. Every strategy we develop focuses on sustainable, long-term organic growth that builds your brand authority and reduces ongoing marketing costs.

2. Training & Empowerment Approach: Unlike agencies that create dependency, we train your team to manage and understand their own digital marketing. You'll gain the knowledge to make informed decisions and reduce reliance on external agencies over time.

3. AI Expertise: We're at the forefront of AI implementation for SMEs, helping businesses leverage cutting-edge technology without the enterprise-level price tag. From Answer Engine Optimization to automated content workflows, we make AI accessible and practical.

4. Northern Ireland Focus: We understand the specific challenges, opportunities, and business culture of Northern Ireland and Ireland. Our strategies are tailored to the local market while maintaining competitiveness across the UK.

5. SME Specialists: We work exclusively with small and medium enterprises, which means our services, pricing, and approach are designed for businesses like yours—not corporate enterprises with unlimited budgets.

6. Proven Track Record: Our podcast, educational content, and client results demonstrate our expertise and commitment to transparency. We practice what we preach, and our own organic growth validates our strategies.

7. Honest Communication: We'll tell you what you need to hear, not what you want to hear. If a strategy won't work for your business, we'll say so—even if it means less revenue for us.

1. How will Instagram's new algorithm update affect my small business's reach? The update introduces more user control over content preferences, which means your reach will increasingly depend on genuine engagement and relationship-building rather than gaming the algorithm. Businesses that focus on quality content, authentic interactions, and consistent engagement with their audience will actually benefit from these changes. The key is diversifying your content types (not just Reels) and prioritising the engagement hierarchy: shares, saves, comments, and likes—in that order.

2. Should I stop posting Reels now that the algorithm has changed? Absolutely not! Reels remain an important content format, but they should no longer be your only strategy. Instagram's multiple algorithms treat different content types differently, so a balanced approach using Reels, Stories, carousel posts, and single images will give you the best overall visibility. The mistake businesses made was relying solely on Reels for growth—diversification has always been important, and now it's essential.

3. What exactly are "recycled content" penalties, and how do I avoid them? Instagram penalises content that has clearly been reposted from other platforms (particularly TikTok videos with watermarks) or content that's been widely circulated elsewhere without original value. To avoid penalties, create platform-specific content, remove watermarks, add original captions and value, and ensure your content provides something unique. The restrictions primarily affect your ability to reach non-followers, so focus on deepening relationships with existing followers while creating genuinely original content for growth.

4. Is using scheduling tools like Buffer going to hurt my Instagram performance? No. Instagram has confirmed that using approved third-party scheduling tools does not negatively impact your reach. However, if you notice sudden drops in reach after scheduling posts, check your analytics for other factors—timing, content quality, engagement rates—rather than blaming the tool itself. The key is monitoring your performance data and adjusting based on what actually works for your specific audience.

5. How can Belfast and Northern Ireland businesses compete with larger UK companies on Instagram? Your local advantage is actually more powerful now than ever. The algorithm's emphasis on relationships and past interactions means your community connections, customer relationships, and local engagement will drive better reach than simply having more followers. Focus on building genuine connections with your local audience, collaborate with other Northern Ireland businesses, use location tags strategically, and create content that resonates with your specific community. Authenticity beats budget every time with these algorithm changes.

6. What should I prioritise: views, likes, comments, saves, or shares? Instagram's revealed engagement hierarchy places shares at the top, followed by saves, then comments, with likes being the least valuable. Shares indicate that someone values your content enough to recommend it to their network. Saves suggest your content has lasting reference value. Comments show active engagement. Likes, while still positive signals, carry the least algorithmic weight. Create content that people want to share and save—educational, valuable, entertaining, or emotionally resonant posts that serve a purpose beyond passive consumption.

7. How does Instagram SEO work, and what should I optimise? Instagram SEO involves optimising your profile name, username, bio, captions, alt text, and hashtags for discoverability. Use relevant keywords in your bio that describe what you do and who you serve. Write detailed captions that include searchable terms your audience might use. Add alt text to every post with descriptive, keyword-rich content. Use a strategic mix of broad and niche hashtags (aim for 8-15 per post). Your profile should clearly communicate your value proposition within seconds of someone discovering you.

8. Should my business be worried about AI-generated content penalties? Instagram is following Google's lead by prioritising quality and originality over content creation method. AI-generated content isn't automatically penalised, but low-quality, generic, or obviously AI-generated content without human editing and original value will perform poorly. If you use AI tools (which can be incredibly efficient for SMEs), ensure you're editing, adding original insights, maintaining your brand voice, and providing genuine value. The focus should always be on the end result's quality, not the tools used to create it.

9. How important is responding quickly to comments for algorithmic performance? Very important. Instagram's algorithm monitors how quickly you respond to comments, interpreting rapid responses as a signal that your content generates valuable conversations. Aim to respond to comments within the first hour of posting when possible, and certainly within the first few hours. This not only boosts your algorithmic ranking but also encourages more people to comment (since they see you're actively engaged), creating a positive feedback loop that increases your overall reach.

10. What does an "omni-channel" approach mean for a small business with limited time and resources? Omni-channel doesn't mean being everywhere all the time—it means strategically diversifying your digital presence so you're not dependent on any single platform's algorithm changes. For most SMEs, this means having a solid WordPress website (your owned property that no algorithm controls), being active on 2-3 social platforms where your audience actually engages, maintaining an email list, and potentially creating video or podcast content. Start with what you can manage consistently, then expand. Quality presence on fewer channels beats mediocre presence everywhere.

Belfast Office: ProfileTree McSweeney Centre 31 Henry Place Belfast BT15 2AY Northern Ireland

Website: www.profiletree.com

Email: Contact us through our website for personalised digital marketing consultations, AI training enquiries, or to discuss your specific business needs.

Follow Us on Social Media:
Stay connected with us on social media for more tips, insights, and behind-the-scenes content:
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@profiletree
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/profiletree...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ProfileTree
X (Twitter): https://x.com/ProfileTree
Pinterest: https://uk.pinterest.com/profiletree/

Never miss an episode! Subscribe to the ProfileTree YouTube channel and hit the notification bell to get alerted when we release new content every week.

Coming up in future episodes:

• Answer Engine Optimization: Preparing for AI-powered search dominance
• AI Tools Every Northern Ireland SME Should Be Using in 2025
• WordPress Security: Protecting Your Business Website from threats
• Local SEO Secrets: Dominating Belfast and Northern Ireland search results
• Video Marketing on a Budget: Creating professional content without expensive equipment
• Email Marketing That Actually Converts: Building and nurturing your list
• TikTok for Business: Is it worth it for Northern Ireland SMEs?
• Content Creation Workflows: How to produce more in less time with AI
• Customer Journey Mapping: Understanding your audience's path to purchase
• Analytics Deep Dive: Measuring what actually matters for business growth

Got questions or topics you'd like us to cover? Leave a comment below, reach out on social media, or contact us directly through our website. We create content based on what Northern Ireland businesses actually need to know.

Primary Keywords: Instagram algorithm update, Instagram marketing Northern Ireland, Instagram SEO, social media marketing Belfast, organic Instagram growth, Instagram algorithm 2025, Instagram business strategy, Instagram engagement tips, social media marketing Ireland, Instagram algorithm changes

Secondary Keywords: digital marketing Belfast, SME marketing Northern Ireland, social media strategy Ireland, Instagram for business UK, organic social media growth, Instagram algorithm explained, social media marketing without ads, Belfast digital marketing agency, Northern Ireland marketing services, Instagram tips for small business

Service Areas: Belfast, Northern Ireland, Ireland, United Kingdom, Derry/Londonderry, Lisburn, Newry, Armagh, Bangor, Ballymena, Craigavon, Antrim, Newtownabbey, Carrickfergus, Coleraine, Omagh, Larne, Banbridge, Enniskillen, Dungannon, Downpatrick, Cookstown, Ballymoney, Limavady, Strabane, Magherafelt

Industries Served: Professional services, retail, hospitality, healthcare, technology, e-commerce, education, construction, manufacturing, financial services, creative industries, tourism, food and beverage, beauty and wellness, automotive, real estate, legal services, recruitment, trades and home services

Content Type: Digital marketing podcast, Instagram marketing tutorial, social media strategy guide, algorithm update explanation, business marketing advice

Expertise Areas: Instagram marketing, social media strategy, organic growth strategies, SEO, WordPress development, AI implementation, video production, digital marketing training, Answer Engine Optimization, content marketing, omni-channel marketing, local marketing

© 2025 ProfileTree. All rights reserved.

This video and description are provided for educational purposes. While we strive for accuracy, Instagram's algorithm continues to evolve. Always test strategies with your specific audience and monitor your analytics for best results. ProfileTree specialises in training businesses to adapt to digital marketing changes—contact us to learn more about our AI training and organic marketing services designed specifically for Northern Ireland SMEs.

#InstagramAlgorithm #InstagramMarketing #DigitalMarketingNorthernIreland #BelfastBusiness #SMEMarketing #SocialMediaStrategy #OrganicGrowth #InstagramSEO #ProfileTree #NorthernIrelandBusiness #DigitalMarketingPodcast #InstagramTips #SocialMediaMarketing #BelfastMarketing #IrishBusiness