BT & Sal immediately address the "elephant in the room"—the widely reported, yet unofficial, inevitable return of Craig Carton—and the future implications for their show. With that out of the way, the focus shifts to the Giants' "unstable mess." Sal emphatically argues that Joe Shane's four-year tenure has resulted in regression, and his continued presence should be a "fireable offense" that owner John Mara must correct. Tierney argues that, despite the chaos, the Giants job is now "incredibly appealing" due to the presence of QB Jaxson Dart and the potential for a clean GM/Coach synergy, possibly featuring a proven veteran like Thomas Dimitroff. They debate whether a big name like Bill Belichick is the right fit, with Tierney questioning if Belichick's age and the "unnecessary noise" from his personal life could be a problem in the high-pressure New York market. Finally, they cover the Perfect Parlay standings, with BT on a heater (6-0 in the last two weeks!) surging past Sal, who declares he's playing "under protest" due to a half-point line discrepancy on his missed Turkey Day Teaser.