A steamboat monopoly, a federal license, and a constitutional power that still shapes our economy—this is the story of Gibbons v. Ogden told through clear facts and sharp reasoning. We dig into how a seemingly straightforward dispute over navigation between New York and New Jersey became a landmark on the meaning of the Commerce Clause and the reach of federal supremacy.
We walk through the clash of dueling licenses and explain why navigation counts as commerce when routes cross state lines. From there, we unpack Chief Justice Marshall’s move away from “strict construction,” his broader definition of commerce as traffic and intercourse, and his pivotal reading of “among the several states” as intermingled activity that does not stop at border lines. Those words solved the case, but they also set the stage for future fights over railroads, highways, and modern markets that span supply chains far beyond any one state’s boundary.
Then we tackle the language that launched a thousand citations: Marshall’s distinction between national “external” concerns and “completely internal” state commerce. That neat line sounds clear until you ask how often commerce is truly sealed within one state. We show why this dicta mattered, how it influenced twentieth‑century expansions and modern limits, and why the facts here—major rivers, multi‑state routes, and Congress’s explicit licensing law—drive a clean holding of federal preemption. We also mark the boundary between this case and the dormant Commerce Clause, where courts police state burdens on interstate trade when Congress has not acted.
If you care about how federal power keeps a national market from fracturing—whether on rivers, rails, or digital platforms—this conversation gives you a usable map. Enjoy the deep dive, and if it helped clarify a classic case, follow the show, share it with a friend, and leave a quick review to support more clear‑eyed civics.

Check Out the Civic Literacy Curriculum!

School of Civic and Economic Thought and Leadership

Center for American Civics