The Truth About Recruiting: Transfer Portal Chaos, High School Choices, and Why Most Families Get It Wrong
Football 360 Show: NIL, D1 recruiting, Transfer portal, Athletic Development, Strength Training.
Manage episode 520537081 series 3563540
Hosts: JP Rock & Matt Biermann Platform: Football 360 Show — The Fastest 48 Minutes in Football Presented By:
Game Plan Strategies — Football consulting for parents & players
OFFRD (getoffrd.com) — Recruiting tools, email templates, coach database & profile tracking
In this episode, JP and Matt deliver a brutally honest breakdown of the 2025 recruiting landscape. They dig deep into the transfer portal chaos, why seniors are panicking, what parents misunderstand about exposure, and the real way college coaches evaluate players.
They also dive into a major parent question: How do you pick the right high school for your kid? Plus — the truth about NAIA/D2 opportunities, pipeline schools, walking on in the Power 4 era, and why most players sabotage their chances by not responding to coaches.
This is one of the most important episodes of the year for football families.
🔑 Key Topics Covered 1. Transfer Portal Chaos & Signing Period Reality800+ D2/D3 players already in the portal — and the tidal wave hasn't hit yet
Portal rules that should help high school players… but not immediately
Why the second signing period (February) matters more than ever
Why seniors should not panic — schools look until June
You can't "turn recruiting on" after film drops — no coach is waiting for your HUDL link
For every 100 actions, expect 1 real response
The myth: "I emailed five coaches and none responded."
The truth: Coaches are drowning in players + portal chaos
10,000+ coach emails & contacts
Track opens, clicks, and view metrics
Education layer: visits, timelines, communication templates
Why players who use the platform properly stand out immediately
Why many recruits vastly overestimate their level
Brutally honest level assessment from JP & Matt
If you think you're "too good" for NAIA or D2 — you probably don't love football
Early playing time vs. chasing logos
Parents chasing "invite-only" combines that mean nothing
The dangerous mindset: "We need the invite so we can post it"
REAL outcomes come from verified performance + competing vs. top players
Example: Roccco Marriott blowing up after competing — not because of an invite
Why walk-on spots are more competitive than ever
Coaches projecting roster needs 6–12 months out
Walk-ons now part of revenue share → coaches are picky
Why "preferred walk-on" ≠ automatic playing opportunity
Major factors JP & Matt outline:
System fit (run-heavy? pass-heavy? trench-focused?)
Starting opportunity by sophomore year
Roster depth at your position
Whether the school produces pipeline exposure
Coaching stability
Past & current players with college interest
How long it takes to "ingrain" into the program
The massive risk of transferring as a senior (eligibility + losing recruiting traction)
Real example: high-level recruit ruled ineligible for half the season
Killed exposure
Set back recruiting timeline
Momentum matters — coaches recruit where the heat is
"Fanboy coaches" steering kids wrong
Advisors who take kids on visits like they are getting recruited
When to know someone is hurting your process
Why real consulting (Game Plan Strategies) matters more than ever
Families traveling nationwide chasing meaningless combines
The $399 camp is the cheap part — travel costs kill families
How to know which camps matter
When to stop wasting money and build a real plan
Rocco Marriott: from combining MVP → JMU offer → 4-star jump
Two top-10 Missouri players who exploded after verified combine results
High-profile QB households balancing system fit vs. depth chart
Real cases of transfer eligibility disasters (MISHAA)
Pipeline schools vs. development-only programs
Navigate recruiting with an honest, personalized plan. Free consults available at GPSFootball.org
OFFRD Recruiting PlatformSend emails, track opens, connect with 10,000+ college coaches. Parent/player education + full recruiting task engine. Learn more at getoffrd.com
📺 Where to Watch & ListenYouTube: Football 360 Show
X: @Football360Show
Radio: 590 AM KLIS — Saturdays @ 12PM
Podcast: Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts
Website: Football360Show.com
105 episodes