Manage episode 512878444 series 3682696
FICO changed their licensing model and two public companies lost 10-20% in a single day. ChatGPT launched shopping with Shopify.
European founders are fleeing to San Francisco.
These look unrelated - but they're all the same story: Infrastructure owners are systematically eliminating middlemen.
Story 1: How FICO destroyed $5 billion in market cap overnight:
- FICO launched "Mortgage Direct License Program" - boring name, brutal market reaction
- Equifax stock dropped 8.4%, TransUnion crashed 10.1% in single trading session
- For decades: FICO charges bureaus ~$5 per score → Bureaus resell to lenders for $10 (100% markup)
- FICO said "we're going direct to lenders, cutting you out" - new price $4.95 per score (50% reduction)
- US mortgage industry is $12 trillion - FICO owns IP, scoring model, algorithms
- Credit bureaus don't own anything valuable - just gatekeepers with smart markups
Why I had to shut down SimpleDirect Financing:
- Announced sunsetting after 4 years because we didn't own end-to-end experience
- We were middleman - sent data to lenders who made final decisions (sometimes instant, sometimes 1-2 days)
- Merchants asking what's going on, homeowners asking what's going on - stuck connecting info in silos
- Problems weren't our fault but we took the heat
- As volume increased: Created silo business, never going to make customers happy, just volume-sending machine
- If you don't own IP, just reselling someone else's API - always at risk
The Credit Karma problem:
- Don't work with FICO directly - work with Equifax/TransUnion
- Those agencies can increase prices, make access harder, introduce new requirements
- Always at mercy of other people's decisions - that's the middleman trap
Story 2: ChatGPT and Shopify just killed Google Ads:
- OpenAI + Shopify announced instant checkout inside ChatGPT
- Ask for product recommendations ("cool sunglasses for Europe trip") → instant Shopify merchant recommendations
- Check out right in chat - no leaving conversation, no merchant website, no account creation, no re-entering card info
- Shopify stock jumped 6% - connecting 1M+ merchants to 700M weekly ChatGPT users
- Calling it "agent commerce" - AI agents as personal shoppers handling entire purchase flow
The Amazon vs Shopify problem just got solved:
- Amazon benefit: Traffic (most visited website, even page 6 products get sales)
- Shopify problem: Own the tech but handle marketing yourself (hard for most merchants)
- Shopify now gives merchants access to 700M weekly users without Google/Facebook/Amazon fees
- Who loses: Google Ads, Facebook Ads, Amazon marketplace fees - all the middlemen taking revenue cuts
But AI desperately needs to monetize:
- ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok all offer free tiers - training costs hundreds of millions to billions
- Running them costs money on every single message sent
- Answer has been "VC money, Saudi/UAE/Qatar billions" but can't last forever
- Elon's xAI adding ads in Grok, ChatGPT testing commerce - all desperate to monetize
- I pay Claude $20/month for heavy coding use, ChatGPT $20/month for daily use (dozen+ times/day)
- Value I get worth way more than $20 but they won't raise prices yet due to competition
Founder friend's startup insight:
- Building company that works with AI platforms + advertisers to inject ads in LLM responses
- Early/frontier stage, working with smaller AI companies desperate to monetize
- But ChatGPT/Claude/Gemini/xAI figuring it out too - with direct distribution advantage
- They can cut out middleman and work directly with advertisers
Story 3: European founders fleeing to America:
- Wall Street Journal: US investors now dominate European AI funding - 71% of deals by value (up from 57% last year)
- European founders doing "Delaware flips" - live in Europe, set up US holding companies for American capital
- One founder: "In London, we'd get half our valuation. In Silicon Valley, investors understand market potential"
- Another raised $500K in SF within a week - had been trying months in London
Why infrastructure wins (my experience from both sides):
- I'm from Canada - run companies in both Canada and US, understand this intimately
- Canadian VCs don't lead rounds - only write support checks after you find US lead
- My thought: Why would I need you if I can find US lead investor? I'll just find US supporting investors who treat me better
- 2022 attempted VC raise: Lead from San Francisco, secondary from New York
- Those guys had money, understood, were risk-takers - wrote $250K angel checks as side thing while running own companies
- Canadian VCs kept asking "Do you have American investors? Do you have lead?" - their LPs won't let them write checks without lead first
US investors vs everyone else:
- Sequoia, a16z, Y Combinator built infrastructure for GLOBAL founders (not just US)
- Write bigger checks, move faster, sometimes commit capital within days
- European/Canadian VCs: Slower, more conservative, smaller checks
- Not just about money - it's about SPEED (in AI, speed beats competitors)
- European funds take months, American funds take weeks
The clear pattern across all three stories:
- FICO: Companies owning IP eliminate markup - bureaus don't own score so got cut out
- ChatGPT/Shopify: Commerce infrastructure eliminates website friction - LLMs become new storefront
- US vs EU capital: Funding infrastructure eliminates slow inefficient middlemen - founders flee to best infrastructure
What this means for your startup - the middle ground is dead:
- Can't be successful as just marked-up reseller
- Can't be slow local fund
- Can't be just website trying to capture traffic
- LLMs, AI, infrastructure owners, IP owners - all squeezing middlemen out
Your two options:
Option 1: Be the infrastructure owner
- Own the IP, algorithm, core value creation
- Be FICO, don't be credit bureau
- Doesn't take years - start now by owning end-to-end experience
- Don't leave core customer experience to another API/provider (slow suicide)
Option 2: Be so lean you don't need middlemen
- Bootstrap as much as possible
- Build global teams (India, Middle East, South America, North America)
- Optimize for efficiency so you don't rely on gatekeepers (gatekeepers getting eliminated)
What you CANNOT be:
- Cannot build business depending on being channel between infrastructure and customers
- I personally made this decision recently - chose not to enter business like that
- Even if going well now, infrastructure partners will eventually squeeze you out
- Not "if" they'll squeeze you - it's "when"
The three critical questions to answer right now:
Q1: Do you own IP/algorithm or reselling someone else's?
- Happens more than you think - okay if answer reveals vulnerability
- If white-labeling or charging markup, you're vulnerable
- AI reducing risk/cost for IP providers to go direct
Q2: Are you destination or can ...
29 episodes