Controlled and uncontrolled components

Frontend First

#Technology #Web #Ember #Software #Development #Design #Web Development #Tech #Software Development #Frontend #Ryan Toronto #Sam Selikoff #JavaScript #Emberjs

50:30

Episode Notes [00:00] The Importance of Questioning [01:21] Introduction to Curated Questions [02:20] Meet Kevin Kelly [03:56] Kevin Kelly's Mentor: Stewart Brand [05:33] The Role of Questions in Intellectual Traditions [06:47] Disequilibrium and Growth [10:21] Embodied Questions and Exploration [11:11] Balancing Exploration and Exploitation [11:50] The Inefficiency of Questioning [15:53] The Abundance Mindset [18:39] The Inevitable and Quality Questions [19:26] Hill Climbing vs. Hill Making [22:28] The Challenge of Innovation [24:13] The Beauty of Engineering and Innovation [24:34] Navigating the Frontier of New Technologies [25:33] The Role of AI in Question Formulation [26:43] Challenges in Advancing AI Capabilities [29:11] The Long Now Foundation and the 10,000 Year Clock [29:56] Transmitting Values Over Time [31:03] Ethics in AI and Self-Driving Cars [33:26] The Art of Questioning [34:04] Photography: Capturing vs. Creating [36:12] The Inefficiency of Exploration [38:36] Daily Practice and Long-Term Success [40:17] The Importance of Quantity for Quality [43:22] Final Thoughts and Encouragement on Questioning [46:24] Summary Takeaways Resources Mentioned Wired Magazine Whole Earth Review WELL Hackers Conference What Technology Wants by Kevin Kelly The Inevitable by Kevin Kelly Cool Tools Project Long Now Foundation Stewart Brand Socratic Method Koan René Descartes Conde Nast Vouge Olivetti Typewriter Trolley Problem Terry Gross Lex Friedman Tim Ferriss KK.org Kevin2Kelly on Instagram Recomendo Newsletter Excellent Advice for Living Beauty Pill Producer Ben Ford Questions Asked When did you first understand the power of questions? Can I do that? Can that be something that you can learn? How did questions function differently between Eastern versus Western intellectual traditions? What role do you think embodied questions those we explore through doing rather than thinking play in developing wisdom? What's on the other side of the hill? What happens if you go to the end? What's the origin of this? How should one think about the exploratory in one's life? Is there anything that you would add to your list of 15 statements that define what makes a quality question? Is there a qualitative difference between the questions humans are asking and the questions our AI systems are beginning to formulate? What do you think would help them get there? Any idea on a forcing function on how we get them [LLMs] to ask the better questions so that they might improve in that direction? What were some novel questions that broke your brain at the time in thinking about this 10,000-year clock or beyond? What's it good for? What would you use it for? What else could you do over the long term for 10,000 years? How do you transmit values over time? How do you evolve values that need to change, and how do you make a difference? How do even know what you don't want to change? What do you want to continue? What's the most essential aspects of our civilization that we don't want to go away? What are the rules? What is the system? How do you pass things along in time and not change the ones you don't wanna change, and make sure you change the ones that are more adaptable so they can adapt? What do you think about questioning itself as an art form? How has being a photographer influenced the way you question reality, visually compared to verbally? Are you a photographer that takes photos or makes photos? What will happen? What will happen next? What are your right now questions that you are wrestling with or working with in your life? Can someone else do what I'm trying to do here? Am I more me in doing my art or more me in doing the writing? Do you have any other thoughts or encouragement about questions that we haven't explored? What makes a good question? How do you ask a good question? What questions do you dwell on to be in purposeful imbalance? What is your practice in embracing the inefficient nature of questions to achieve breakthroughs? What are the new hills you can build and frontiers you can explore? How can you use your curiosity and humanity to pursue questions that trend toward the fringes?…

about a year ago 47:25

MP3•Episode home

0:00 - Intro
1:41 - What are controlled and uncontrolled components?
6:11 - How to change a component from uncontrolled to controlled
8:48 - How do you decide when to use a controlled or uncontrolled component?
12:00 - Sortable table example and a single source of truth
15:27 - Is it always either controlled or uncontrolled?
21:09 - Color picker example and not exposing internal state
28:46 - Sortable list example with Framer Motion
39:45 - Component boundaries and wearing two hats: the library author vs. library consumer
41:43 - How do you know if you are using the wrong approach?

Links:

201 episodes

Controlled and uncontrolled components

Frontend First

214 subscribers

published about a year ago

MP3•Episode home

Timestamps:

0:00 - Intro
1:41 - What are controlled and uncontrolled components?
6:11 - How to change a component from uncontrolled to controlled
8:48 - How do you decide when to use a controlled or uncontrolled component?
12:00 - Sortable table example and a single source of truth
15:27 - Is it always either controlled or uncontrolled?
21:09 - Color picker example and not exposing internal state
28:46 - Sortable list example with Framer Motion
39:45 - Component boundaries and wearing two hats: the library author vs. library consumer
41:43 - How do you know if you are using the wrong approach?

Links:

201 episodes

#Technology #Web #Ember #Software #Development #Design #Web Development #Tech #Software Development #Frontend #Ryan Toronto #Sam Selikoff #JavaScript #Emberjs

All episodes

1
Creating a background gradient from an image 48:39

22 weeks ago48:39

48:39

Ryan talks to Sam about reproducing iOS's new image background treatment for his Open Graph Preview tool, opengraph.ing. They talk about different approaches for generating gradients from images, including finding the vibrant color of an image, luminosity-weighted averages, k-means clustering, and more. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 3:07 - Apple's new OG image gradient 10:06 - Luminosity-weighted average 14:22 - Finding the vibrant color of an image 21:41 - Contrast ratios on favicons 32:21 - K-means clustering 41:25 - Refactoring UI tip about rotating the hue Links: Open Graph Preview Refactoring UI…

1
Exploring useActionState 59:57

26 weeks ago59:57

59:57

Sam and Ryan talk about React 19's useActionState hook. They discuss how adding async functions to a plain React app introduces lots of in-between states that developers must grapple with, and how useActionState allows React to collapse and eliminate these states, bringing the simplicity of React's sync mental model to our async code. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 1:51 - How React normally eliminates state in synchronous apps 8:20 - How useActionState lets React eliminate state in asynchronous apps 18:17 - Why you shouldn't just pass server actions into useActionState 23:00 - TCP/IP and UDP analogy 26:39 - Thinking of useActionState like enqueue 34:55 - Why the term "reducer" is too loaded for best understanding useActionState 51:07 - How useActionState helps you build a Todo app that stays responsive during pending actions…

1
Cloudflare Tunnel | React Compiler | refs during render 42:46

28 weeks ago42:46

42:46

Sam and Ryan talk about using Cloudflare Tunnel for local development, the new React Compiler beta release, and why reading or writing refs during render violates the rules of React. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 1:42 - Cloudflare Tunnel 7:06 - React Compiler 14:21 - Reading or writing refs during render Links: Cloudflare Tunnel React Compiler Beta release React Docs Pitfall on refs…

1
useAnimatedText | Events vs. State Changes | Catalyst 1:08:19

29 weeks ago1:08:19

1:08:19

Sam and Ryan talk about building a useAnimatedText hook that can animate streaming text. They also discuss how React code that uses state changes to approximate events can be simplified, and the benefits of having escape hatches when building UI with Catalyst. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 1:22 - Catalyst and escape hatches 16:03 - Building a useAnimatedText hook (aka useBufferedText) 54:10 - Avoiding using state changes to approximate events Links: Catalyst Sam's Tweet about useBufferedText and AnimatedScroller useAnimatedText recipe Intl.Segmenter on MDN David K's Tweet on events Ricky's Tweet on Intersection Observer Build UI's new course…

1
Can you self-host Next.js? 58:03

31 weeks ago58:03

58:03

Sam and Ryan talk about how frameworks and infrastructure evolve with each other, using Next.js as a representative example. They discuss how hosting providers like Heroku have always imposed certain constraints on apps, what features those constraints enable hosting providers to support, how burdensome those constraints are across different frameworks, and how frameworks that add infra-specific APIs can best communicate the costs of those APIs and benefits they enable. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 3:03 - Heroku and the Twelve-Factor App 7:39 - GitHub Pages and static sites 13:57 - Serverless and JAMstack 17:30 - Vercel and CDNs, self-hosting, and Next.js 19:00 - How framework APIs can nudge an app towards a particular hosting solution 23:09 - What constraints does Next.js impose on your app (e.g. middleware doesn't run node), and what benefits do those constraints give you? 36:13 - How Next.js APIs are motivated by wanting to tease apart static and dynamic code, in an attempt to support the needs of any web app with a single stack 40:33 - What is the relationship between frameworks and infra? 47:37 - How can frameworks that add infra-specific APIs best communicate the costs of those APIs and the benefits they enable? Links: The Twelve-Factor App…

1
Tom Occhino on the future of React 1:00:27

35 weeks ago1:00:27

1:00:27

Tom Occhino, Chief Product Officer at Vercel and former Engineering Director at Facebook, joins Sam to talk about the pivotal moments in React's history. He talks about how React popularized the ideas of declarative rendering and unidirectional data flow, how GraphQL furthered React's goal of co-locating all the concerns of a particular piece of UI, the problems that GraphQL led to at Facebook and how Relay solved them, and how Suspense, Server Components, and PPR are the generalized spiritual successors to the stack used at Facebook. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 2:53 - Declarative rendering as React's legacy 8:12 - How GraphQL enabled complex components to be fully self-contained 20:12 - How React's goal has always been to co-locate all the concerns of a particular piece of UI 22:58 - The problem with co-locating GraphQL with components, and how Relay solved it 26:28 - How RSC is the generalized spiritual successor to BigPipe and GraphQL 34:46 - What PPR is, and how it and Suspense fit into this story 55:55 - The general paradigm shift of getting static code to the device as soon as possible Links: Tom Occhino with Ben Dunphy React: The Documentary React Roundtable with Andrew Clark and Sebastian Markbåge Tom Occhino on Twitter…

1
Render props 34:43

36 weeks ago34:43

34:43

Sam and Ryan talk about render props in React. They discuss where they came from, how Hooks superseded them for sharing stateful logic, how data attributes compare to them for customizing styling, and how for certain complex components like forms they're still a great solution for accessing slices of internal state. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 3:40 - Where did render props come from? 6:01 - How hooks replaced many use cases for render props 8:14 - Using render props for custom styling 10:32 - Data attributes vs. render props for custom styling 16:43 - Using render props to peek into an uncontrolled component's internal state 21:05 - Forms example and using render props for a smaller public API 24:10 - React docs mention of render props 25:48 - Where render props shine Links: Headless UI Menu Radix Forms React Aria Forms React docs - Render props Our upcoming course on React Component Patterns Email Sam Email Ryan…

1
Controlled and uncontrolled components 47:25

38 weeks ago47:25

47:25

Sam and Ryan discuss controlled and uncontrolled components in React. They talk about how uncontrolled components can be thought of as components that manage their own internal state, why you should model your complex React components after the simpler APIs of native HTML elements like inputs, why you shouldn't try to make components that are both controlled and uncontrolled, and why making a new component boundary is sometimes all you need to make your custom components behave more predictably. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 1:41 - What are controlled and uncontrolled components? 6:11 - How to change a component from uncontrolled to controlled 8:48 - How do you decide when to use a controlled or uncontrolled component? 12:00 - Sortable table example and a single source of truth 15:27 - Is it always either controlled or uncontrolled? 21:09 - Color picker example and not exposing internal state 28:46 - Sortable list example with Framer Motion 39:45 - Component boundaries and wearing two hats: the library author vs. library consumer 41:43 - How do you know if you are using the wrong approach? Links: New course: Advanced React Component Patterns React docs: Controlled and uncontrolled components React docs: Storing state from previous renders Email Sam Email Ryan Frontend First on Twitter…

1
Unstyled React components 34:08

40 weeks ago34:08

34:08

Sam and Ryan talk about the pattern of building unstyled components with React. They discuss why unstyled components were created, how they improve upon composition patterns from UI libraries like Bootstrap, how they can be used to share behavior and logic without prescribing any styling opinions, and how they fit into a larger collection of React patterns that can be used to build more powerful components that avoid premature abstractions. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 1:36 - What are unstyled components? 2:24 - How do unstyled components improve upon earlier patterns? 6:44 - Why would you want to use an unstyled component? 9:58 - How can you compose an unstyled component with a styled component? 16:41 - How to decide which pattern is best suited for the code you want to share 19:36 - Using patterns that preserve React's locality of behavior 24:49 - How do you know if an abstraction is good? 32:54 - Build UI's upcoming course on Advanced React Component Patterns Links: Build UI's newest course: Advanced React Component Patterns Sam's YouTube video on Recursive Components Email Sam Email Ryan…

1
What is a framework? 1:02:38

41 weeks ago1:02:38

1:02:38

Sam and Ryan talk about what sorts of capabilities a tool should have to be considered a web framework. They discuss how frameworks tackle the complexity of getting different systems to communicate with each other, how good frameworks embrace the strengths and patterns of the language they're written in, and why frameworks and services are not in opposition to each other. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 3:58 - Adapter pattern and cohesive boundaries 9:43 - Rails is Omakase 13:47 - Configurable, but still cohesive 17:04 - Frontend frameworks try to “work with everything” 21:42 - Does composition mean a React framework will look different than Rails? 29:29 - Why taste still matters 34:20 - A framework is a shell of adapters and a brain that coordinates them 35:16 - When using services, complexity still exists in the in-between 37:59 - A fullstack dev is someone who acknowledges and understands how all the parts come together 44:06 - Tweets about the hard problems that Laravel tackles, and the deep design it took to get there 49:15 - Frameworks should embrace the strengths and patterns of their language and ecosystem 50:35 - Why RSCs and Server Actions mean the “Rails for JS” may end up looking nothing like Rails 52:11 - Why users of a “fullstack framework” shouldn’t even care about where the code is running 55:31 - Why libraries or services that are easy to install and set up are not a replacement for frameworks Links: Sam's BigSkyDevCon talk Rails is omakase Povilas' Laravel tweet Mary's Laravel tweet Build UI's upcoming React Component Patterns course Email Sam Email Ryan…

1
Crossover: Declaring War Against the Frontend 59:17

42 weeks ago59:17

59:17

Sam joins Lane Wagner in a crossover episode with the Backend Banter podcast. They talk about abstractions in frontend and backend frameworks, what JavaScript is doing differently from other languages and frameworks, why the frontend should drive the backend even if you're building in a server-side framework, and what's so special about React Server Components. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 2:12 - When abstractions leak 6:37 - Recap of Sam's BigSky talk 10:51 - What is JavaScript doing differently? 19:10 - Why frontend frameworks should have more backend features 24:04 - Strong opinions on a library level 30:29 - Shipping more standardized interfaces 37:06 - The frontend should be driving everything in the backend 39:12 - Your types should flow from the database to the frontend, but not your product decisions 46:53 - React Server Components Link: Backend Banter…

1
Blog Post Club: Queueing - An interactive study of queueing strategies 46:27

43 weeks ago46:27

46:27

Sam and Ryan read and discuss a fantastic interactive blog post about queueing in HTTP written by Sam Rose. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 6:57 - Queueing: An interactive study of queueing strategies 9:05 - Why do we need queues? 13:16 - FIFO and timing out 17:55 - LIFO 20:58 - Priority queues 25:21 - Active queue management 29:08 - Comparing queues 36:32 - Conclusion Links: Queueing: An interactive study of queueing strategies Up and Down the Ladder of Abstraction…

1
SPAs in React 19 59:34

44 weeks ago59:34

59:34

Sam and Ryan discuss the new features in React 19 that will specifically benefit developers building single-page applications. They talk about how Suspense and Transitions let developers "teach" React about when their apps are in a loading or a pending state, how Client Actions improve upon using events in React 18 to handle data mutations, and how Actions enable React Components to automatically render and discard optimistic updates without any knowledge of the application's data layer. They also discuss several new Hooks like useOptimistic, useFormStatus, useActionState, and useOptimistic. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 2:19 - How SPAs are built in React 18 5:29 - How Suspense made loading a first-class concept in React 7:48 - The problem with data writes in React 18 10:37 - What are Client Actions? 12:05 - What does it look like to use Actions? 14:13 - What are the benefits of Actions? 18:46 - How does React 19 change the Optimistic UI story? 29:40 - Working with Transitions outside of Actions 36:06 - The useActionState Hook 37:51 - Using Transitions to keep the old UI rendered and responsive 41:25 - How Transitions enable better composition patterns in third-party libraries 43:55 - Building a SortableList that flips between being controlled and uncontrolled Links: React Unpacked: A Roadmap to React 19…

1
High floor, high ceiling 59:24

46 weeks ago59:24

59:24

Sam tells Ryan about a recent talk he gave at BigSkyDevCon. They chat about how backend frameworks are raising the ceiling of what UIs they’re capable of delivering, how frontend frameworks are raising the floor of what backend features they come bundled with, and what each community can learn from the other. Timestamps: 0:00 - Intro 4:23 - Recap of Ryan Florence’s talk 6:49 - Overview of "High floor, high ceiling" 10:02 - Cohesion is the biggest strength of backend frameworks 17:10 - Why doesn’t Rails for JavaScript exist? 23:48 - Locality of behavior is the biggest strength of frontend frameworks 33:14 - The use of lexical scope in React 50:27 - Which community is raising both the floor and ceiling the most? Links: "High floor, high ceiling" talk…

1
Technical Cost vs. Product Benefit 1:14:10

47 weeks ago1:14:10