Send us a text

A single silhouette stalks our map, but it changes its name at every border. We take you on a fast, vivid tour of the nation’s cryptid canon—from the Sierra Sasquatch and Rocky Mountain sightings to the Honey Island Swamp Monster’s webbed prints and Wisconsin’s werewolf-leaning Beast of Bray Road—showing how landscapes, weather, and work culture shape what people hear, smell, and swear they saw. It’s part folklore atlas, part campfire confessional, and part field guide to the eerie sounds that drift in when the sun drops.
We dig into decades of reports that refuse to fade: Murfreesboro’s white-furred Big Muddy Monster with police logs to match, New Hampshire tracks that cross clean snow without a turn, and a Pennsylvania tale of thrown tires that defies easy explanation. A personal lakeshore moment in Michigan—an enormous bottle-blown moan echoing up a bluff—captures the strange choreography of curiosity and fear: you go looking, the dark gives nothing, then the sound answers anyway. We also press on the unsettling theme of mimicry: whistles answered in the White Mountains, turkey calls parroted in deep forest, and the way echoes become messages once a story primes your ears.
Skeptic or believer, there’s something magnetic about a creature that wears local names like stamps in a passport—Menehune echoes in Hawaii, Momo in Missouri, Knobby in North Carolina, Kinderhook in New York, Yahoo in West Virginia. The point isn’t to settle the debate; it’s to map how a shared mystery binds people to their places and to each other. If you’ve hiked past a red-eye glint in Sussex County, heard low growls around the Smokies, or watched prints vanish into fog near Bennington, we want to hear it.
Subscribe, share this with the one friend who swears they don’t spook, and leave a review with your hometown cryptid—what do folks whisper after dark?

Support the show