Send us a text

Campfire whispers have a way of outlasting headlines, but what happens when they start to sound the same? We dive into the legend of Cropsey, tracing its path from summer camp lore near Maston Lake to the shadow it casts over Staten Island, and the unsettling moments where myth seemed to overlap with real cases. Along the way, we unpack the pieces that make a story travel so far for so long: a family tragedy, a vanished avenger, a hook for a hand, and a shuttered institution whose name still chills New Yorkers.
As we dig into the Andre Rand cases and the Willowbrook State School narrative, we explore how communities use legends to explain danger and place invisible fences around kids who wander too close to the edge of the map. The interplay goes both ways—news shapes the legend, the legend shapes how people read the news—and in that feedback loop, Cropsey becomes more than a camp tale. It turns into cultural shorthand for fear that feels local, personal, and always just out of sight. We also share a personal childhood story about a not-so-big patch of trees that felt like a forest when someone you trust pointed at it and said, “Look.”
This is a conversation about more than one name. It’s about why boogeyman stories stick, how they mark boundaries, and how a place can adopt a myth as part of its identity. If folklore, true crime, and the psychology of fear sit on your nightstand next to a flashlight, you’ll find a lot to think about here. Press play, then tell us the legend that haunted your hometown. Subscribe, share the episode with a friend who loves urban legends, and leave a review with your scariest local tale—we might read it on a future show.

Support the show