How Can We Trust Hypertrophy and Nutrition Science? (Eric Helms) | Ep 391
Wits & Weights | Fat Loss, Nutrition, & Strength Training for Lifters
Manage episode 515321731 series 2997456
Get your FREE Muscle-Building Nutrition Blueprint to setup your nutrition, training, recovery, and tracking to build muscle while minimizing fat.
—
How can you tell when science is solid and when it’s just being sold to you?
Dr. Eric Helms returns for his third appearance to unpack how we interpret fitness research, why “evidence-based” doesn’t always mean “accurate,” and what it really takes to think critically about the information you consume.
We break down the philosophy of knowledge and why understanding how we know things leads to better results. Eric and I unpack skepticism vs. cynicism, spotting red flags in “sciencey” claims, and balancing real-world experience with research. You’ll also learn a simple framework to stay curious without getting misled.
Today, you’ll learn all about:
2:25 – Setting the stage for scientific thinking
10:50 – Why critical thinking beats blind belief
15:07 – The meaning of epistemology
25:01 – How empiricism changed modern science
34:52 – What black swans teach us about truth
48:27 – Cynicism vs. healthy skepticism
59:50 – Making sense of the hierarchy of evidence
1:12:56 – Turning data into practical results
1:28:50 – Where to find credible fitness research
Episode resources:
- MASS Research Review
- On Google Scholar: Eric R Helms, h-index: 35, i10-index: 68, and cited by 6811
- On PubMed - PMID: 24092765, with 89 articles (including 20 preprints)
- Instagram: @helms3dmj
- Facebook: @ericrhelms
- Threads: @helms3dmj
- YouTube: @Team3DMJ
🔥 Take our 2-minute Metabolic Quiz for a free, personalized fat loss blueprint with training and nutrition recommendations
🩸 Book a Performance Bloodwork Analysis to find out what's slowing your metabolism, fat loss, & muscle gain (20% off with VITALITY20)
🎓 Lose fat + build muscle in Physique University (use code FREEPLAN for a free custom nutrition plan)
👥 Join our Facebook community for fitness support
👋 Ask a question or find me on Instagram
📱 Try MacroFactor 2 weeks free with code WITSANDWEIGHTS (my favorite nutrition and macros app)
Chapters
1. Can We Trust Fitness Research? (00:00:00)
2. Introducing Eric Helms And The Mission (00:01:06)
3. Science, Hype, And Conflicts Of Interest (00:03:04)
4. Cynicism Versus Skepticism Online (00:07:51)
5. Ontology Before Epistemology (00:12:13)
6. Positivism, Constructivism, Critical Realism (00:18:02)
7. Why Empiricism Wins In Practice (00:24:28)
8. Falsification And The Black Swan Lesson (00:29:54)
9. Evidence Hierarchy And Meta-Analysis (00:36:12)
10. From Averages To Individuals (00:44:05)
11. Anecdotes, Placebos, And Real-World Decisions (00:50:23)
12. Using N=1 Without Fooling Yourself (00:57:08)
13. Diet Breaks, Refeeds, And Saying “I Don’t Know” (01:04:20)
14. How Studies Are Actually Born (01:10:05)
15. Where To Learn How To Learn (01:16:18)
16. Practical Resources And Closing (01:20:24)
543 episodes